Fertility Awareness Biomarkers

Self-Monitoring of Fertility Hormones: A New Era for Natural Family Planning?

Blackwell L, Cooke D, Brown S

Published February 2018 The Linacre Quarterly, 85(1), 26-34
DOI 10.1177/0024363918756387 PMID 29970935 PMC PMC6027114

RRM Academy Synopsis

Urinary hormone tracking shows ovulation directly, a review argues

A review article in The Linacre Quarterly argues that urinary hormone tests show ovulation more clearly than mucus, temperature, or LH signs. Most natural family planning (NFP) methods use these indirect markers. The authors describe cycles where signs are missing or hard to read, and they propose adding home hormone tests.

Study at a glance, narrative review: Urinary hormone tests may show ovulation more clearly than mucus or temperature
Study at a glance, narrative review: Urinary hormone tests may show ovulation more clearly than mucus or temperature. Source: Blackwell L et al., 2018, PMID 29970935.

Key Findings

  • A meta-analysis the authors cite puts missing LH peaks at about 13 percent of cycles (0 percent to 57 percent across reports); 101 of 113 normal cycles had a discernible peak.
  • A meta-analysis cited by the authors suggests mucus symptoms go unreported in about 10 percent of cycles in apparently normal cycling women (0 percent to 24 percent across reports).
  • A meta-analysis cited by the authors finds no basal body temperature shift in about 2 percent of apparently normal cycling women (0 percent to 69 percent across reports).
  • In a population with supposedly normal cycles, it is not unusual for 10–20 percent to be disordered, usually without ovulation or with a deficient luteal phase.
  • Hormone results show that regular bleeding can occur in cycles without ovulation, so a history of regular cycles is only partially evidence of regular ovulation.

Interpretation

The article is a narrative review comparing mucus, temperature, and LH observations with daily urinary hormone tests. The review cites a World Health Organization–sponsored study that compared records from trained NFP users with urinary hormone data. The authors state that NFP works well for many women. They call for more research on early mucus peaks and on how mucus and temperature signs relate to progesterone.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine checks whether and when ovulation happens before treatment starts. Hormone tests give a direct measure of that event. The authors point to the Marquette method as a partial blend of a home hormone monitor with fertility awareness charting. A chart that pairs daily signs with hormone readings gives a couple and a clinician one record of when ovulation occurred.

Abstract

Natural family planning (NFP) methods have served many generations well, and in particular, the symptothermal or symptohormonal methods. The comparison of daily mucus and temperature records for individual cycles with daily hormone measurements, which is now possible, shows that some of the assumptions underlying NFP may not be completely accurate. The various methods are inadvertently depending on an element of chance, which, of course, cannot be known by the NFP user. However, it is statistically inevitable that such errors will result eventually in an unexpected pregnancy, and these discrepancies are the likely reason for the method failures. Further research and integration of home hormone measurements with NFP symptoms are needed.

Summary

Traditional NFP methods, based on the observations of temperature, mucus, and luteinizing hormone, can work well. However, these data are sometimes difficult to interpret, and significant changes in the variables are sometimes "missing" from some cycles. Changes in these variables are elicited by the estrogen and progesterone released from the ovaries. It follows that the direct measures of events in the ovaries are the levels of estrogen and progesterone or their derivatives in blood or urine. Measurements of urinary derivatives of estrogen and progesterone can be used to monitor the ovaries directly and are clearer indicators than traditional NFP methods.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Fertility Awareness › Biomarkers › Urinary Hormone Monitoring · Menstrual Cycle › Cycle Biomarkers › Hormonal Markers · Reproductive Endocrinology › Ovarian Hormones › Progesterone
Leonard Blackwell, Delwyn Cooke, Simon Brown
L Blackwell, D Cooke, S Brown
PMID 29970935 29970935 DOI 10.1177/0024363918756387 10.1177/0024363918756387 Blackwell et al. 2018, Blackwell 2018