Fertility Awareness Effectiveness

Use effectiveness of the Creighton model ovulation method of natural family planning

Fehring RJ, Lawrence D, Philpot C

Published May 1994 Journal of Obstetric, Gynecologic, and Neonatal Nursing : JOGNN, 23(4), 303-309
DOI 10.1111/j.1552-6909.1994.tb01881.x PMID 8057183

RRM Academy Synopsis

Creighton Model 98.0% use effective in avoiding pregnancy at 12 months

The Creighton Model was 98.0% use effective in avoiding pregnancy by the end of the first year. A prospective, descriptive study followed 242 couples taught the method at a university nursing center. Among those couples, use effectiveness in achieving pregnancy was 24.4% at 12 months.

Study at a glance, prospective, descriptive: Creighton Model was 98.0% use effective in avoiding pregnancy at 12 months
Study at a glance, prospective, descriptive of 242 couples: Creighton Model was 98.0% use effective in avoiding pregnancy at 12 months. Source: Fehring RJ et al., 1994, PMID 8057183.

Key Findings

  • By the 12th month of use, method effectiveness in avoiding pregnancy was 98.8% and use effectiveness was 98.0%, equal to 1.2 and 2.0 pregnancies per 100 couples.
  • Couples using the model to achieve pregnancy reached a use effectiveness of 13.6 per 100 at 6 months and 24.4 per 100 at 12 months.
  • Among the 242 couples, 65 pregnancies occurred during the 12-month period, and most of them were achieving-related pregnancies.
  • Three earlier Creighton Model studies, published in 1980, 1985 and 1990, reported 12-month use effectiveness in avoiding pregnancy of 94.8%, 96.2% and 97.4%, against 98.0% here.

Interpretation

Researchers followed the couples from enrollment in a university nursing center program, between October 1984 and May 1992, and analyzed the data with life-table methods. Each pregnancy was evaluated within the first 3 months and classified by the couple's behavior. A pregnancy was classified as achieving-related when partners using the method to avoid pregnancy chose intercourse on a day they knew to be fertile and the woman conceived. The authors conclude that effectiveness depends on qualified teachers. They note a relatively small, homogeneous sample and call for larger studies with more diverse populations.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine treats the menstrual cycle as clinical information. The Creighton Model applies that principle through cervical mucus charting and a standard teaching format. Its practitioners complete a year-long accredited training program. The same charts give NaProTechnology the cycle-timed record behind its evaluation and treatment.

Abstract

Objective

To determine the use effectiveness of the Creighton model ovulation method in avoiding and achieving pregnancy.

Design

Prospective, descriptive.

Setting

A natural family planning clinic at a university nursing center.

Participants

Records and charts from 242 couples who were taught the Creighton model. The sample represented 1,793 months of use of the model.

Main Outcome Measures

Creighton model demographic forms and logbook.

Results

At 12 months of use, the Creighton model was 98.8% method effective and 98.0% use effective in avoiding pregnancy. It was 24.4% use effective in achieving pregnancy. The continuation rate for the sample at 12 months of use was 78.0%.

Conclusion

The Creighton model is an effective method of family planning when used to avoid or achieve pregnancy. However, its effectiveness depends on its being taught by qualified teachers. The effectiveness rate of the Creighton model is based on the assumption that if couples knowingly use the female partner's days of fertility for genital intercourse, they are using the method to achieve pregnancy.

Read the guides

  • Fertility Awareness Methods Compared

    Clinician-reviewed comparison of fertility awareness-based methods (Billings, Creighton, Sensiplan, Marquette, Standard Days, apps). Every effectiveness figure cited and labeled by metric.

    30 min read

  • What Is NaProTechnology? A Guide for Patients Looking for a NaPro Doctor

    NaProTechnology diagnoses and treats the underlying conditions driving infertility, menstrual disorders, and early pregnancy loss. This guide covers how the method works, published outcomes data, how to find a qualified provider, and what to expect on cost and insurance.

    18 min read

Topics

By this author

Related research

Fertility Awareness › Effectiveness › Typical and Perfect Use · Restorative Reproductive Medicine › NaProTechnology › Program Outcomes
Richard J. Fehring, Donna Lawrence, Connie Philpot
Rick Fehring, Dick Fehring, Rich Fehring, R Fehring, D Lawrence, C Philpot
PMID 8057183 8057183 DOI 10.1111/j.1552-6909.1994.tb01881.x 10.1111/j.1552-6909.1994.tb01881.x Fehring et al. 1994, Fehring 1994