Shepard, M. K., & Senturia, Y. D. (1977). Comparison of serum progesterone and endometrial biopsy for confirmation of ovulation and evaluation of luteal function. Fertility and Sterility, 28(5), 541-548. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0015-0282(16)42554-9
Shepard MK, Senturia YD. Comparison of serum progesterone and endometrial biopsy for confirmation of ovulation and evaluation of luteal function. Fertil Steril. 1977;28(5):541-548. doi:10.1016/s0015-0282(16)42554-9
Shepard, Marguerite K., and Yvonne D. Senturia. "Comparison of serum progesterone and endometrial biopsy for confirmation of ovulation and evaluation of luteal function." Fertility and Sterility, vol. 28, no. 5, 1977, pp. 541-548.
For EndNote, Zotero or Mendeley:
Open access
Free to read
No reuse license
Free to read at the publisher (reported by Unpaywall and OpenAlex, not verified by RRM Academy)
Author affiliations
1 institution
The University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio02f6dcw23
Linked to ROR, the Research Organization Registry
RRM Academy Synopsis
Blood progesterone fit presumed ovulation timing better than biopsy
A 1977 Texas study followed 55 infertile women. Doctors checked a blood progesterone test against a same-visit biopsy of the uterine lining. Blood progesterone matched the presumed day of ovulation more often than biopsy did. Across 33 usable cycles, blood matched about 9 out of 10 times. Biopsy matched about 4 out of 10.
Key Findings
Among 53 analyzable cycles, blood progesterone confirmed ovulation in 90.5% and biopsy showed secretory endometrium in 81%. The paper calls the difference not significant.
Only 33 cycles had enough data to judge luteal function. Biopsy disagreed with the presumed time of ovulation in 20 of them. Blood progesterone disagreed in 2 of the 33.
Just 13 of 33 biopsies landed inside the 2-day window called normal. Retarded histology, a lining that looked behind schedule, appeared in 48.5% of biopsies.
In 15 cycles with extra blood samples, a single well-timed progesterone value appeared adequately to reflect the serial samples from the same cycle.
Six of the eight women who later had a viable infant showed retarded endometrium in the study cycle.
Interpretation
This cohort study followed infertile women at one public clinic and one private clinic. Ovulation was dated from the temperature shift or the next period. On that date, blood progesterone was checked against a same-visit biopsy. Blood progesterone matched the presumed day of ovulation much more often than biopsy did. The authors note the data were too thin to judge luteal phase problems. The findings support larger studies comparing blood and tissue tests for the timing of ovulation.
RRM Context
Hormone results depend on knowing the day of ovulation. Here, that day came from temperature charts or the next period. Restorative reproductive medicine builds on cycle charting. It grounds evaluation in a woman's own charted signs.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract
An endometrial biopsy and a blood sample for progesterone determination obtained simultaneously in the midluteal phase of the cycles of 55 infertile women were compared for reliability for confirmation of presumptive ovulation and evaluation of luteal function. Progesterone levels of 3 ng/ml or greater were found in 90.5% of the cycles. Secretory endometrium was identified in 81% of the cycles. Thirty-three cycles yielded sufficient information to compare the two methods for evaluation of luteal function. Histology and progesterone levels were consistent with each other and the presumed time of ovulation in only 11 cycles. Histology was inconsistent with the presumed time of ovulation in 20 cycles, while progesterone was inconsistent in only two cycles. Additional samples for progesterone determinations were obtained during the biopsy cycles of 15 patients who presented adequate data for evaluation of luteal function. A single, well-timed progesterone determination appeared adequately to reflect the data obtained from serial samples in the same cycle. These results support the thesis that a single, well-timed serum progesterone determination is superior to a single endometrial biopsy as a screening method for confirmation of presumptive ovulation and for evaluation of luteal function.