Clinical Guidelines and Standards Guideline Appraisal

Guideline for unexplained couple infertility: misunderstandings on the approach to the male factor

Grande G, Graziani A, Ferlin A

Published April 3, 2024 Human reproduction (Oxford, England)
DOI 10.1093/humrep/deae032 PMID 38423540

RRM Academy Synopsis

Letter argues ESHRE's unexplained infertility guideline undertests men

Critical to restorative reproductive medicine

A 2024 letter to the editor argues that the ESHRE guideline works up the woman in depth but checks the man with a semen test alone. The authors say a normal semen test cannot rule out male factor infertility.

Key Findings

  • The authors say the guideline calls for a broad workup of the woman: ovulation, ovarian reserve, tubes, uterus and vaginal microbiota. They say the man gets semen analysis only.
  • The authors state that judging the testes and the urinary and genital tract takes at least a history, a physical exam, hormone tests and an ultrasound of the testes and seminal tract.
  • The authors write that the WHO manual's reference values come from around 3500 presumed fertile men and mark no dividing line between fertile and infertile men.
  • The authors state that men with results under the fifth percentile can father children naturally, and men above it can be infertile. They conclude a normal ejaculate cannot be defined.

Interpretation

The published abstract is the only source for this entry, and it ends before the authors' conclusion. The piece is a letter to the editor replying to a guideline. The abstract reports no new data. The claims rest on the authors' reading of the guideline text and the WHO semen manual. The stored abstract text includes no reply from the guideline group.

RRM Context

RRM principles include evaluating both partners and looking for the root cause before treatment. The letter's call for a wider male evaluation touches the same principle of full evaluation for both partners. The abstract does not discuss cycle charting.

Abstract not indexed.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Clinical Guidelines and Standards › Guideline Appraisal › Guideline Variation and Disagreement · Male Fertility › Semen Analysis › Reference Standards · Infertility › Evaluation › Diagnostic Workup
Giuseppe Grande, Andrea Graziani, Alberto Ferlin
G Grande, A Graziani, A Ferlin
PMID 38423540 38423540 DOI 10.1093/humrep/deae032 10.1093/humrep/deae032 Grande et al. 2024, Grande 2024