In vitro effects of coital lubricants and synthetic and natural oils on sperm motility

Sandhu RS, Wong TH, Kling CA, Chohan KR

Published April 2014 Fertility and Sterility, 101(4), 941-944
DOI 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2013.12.024 PMID 24462060

RRM Academy Synopsis

Astroglide and KY Lubricants Impair Sperm Motility in Lab Study

In a lab test of semen from 22 men, Astroglide and three KY lubricants sharply cut sperm motility, and the KY products acted fast, within 5 minutes. Pre-Seed, canola oil, baby oil, and mustard oil had little to no lasting effect.

Key Findings

  • Plain mHTF fluid, used as the control, caused no drop in motility over 60 minutes (P = .206).
  • KY Sensitive, Warming, and Tingling cut total motility by 36% to 66% and progressive motility by 43% to 69% within 5 minutes (P < .001). KY Tingling left almost no motile sperm.
  • Astroglide caused a steady drop in motility (P < .001). Sesame oil declined within 5 minutes with no further significant change; the authors grouped both as harmful to sperm.
  • Pre-Seed caused no drop in total motility after 60 minutes (P > .229). Progressive motility fell slightly: 4% at 30 minutes and 7% at 60 minutes (P < .01).
  • Canola and baby oils caused small early drops that did not worsen further. Mustard oil caused no drop (P = .32) but made sperm hyperactive in all 22 samples.

Interpretation

This is a comparative in vitro lab study. Researchers mixed semen from 22 healthy donors with each lubricant or oil. They tracked sperm motility at 5, 30, and 60 minutes. Sesame oil and the synthetic lubricants cut motility and may hurt fertility, the authors conclude. Pre-Seed and the canola, mustard, and baby oils showed no harm and may be sperm-friendly. Mustard oil's hyperactive effect on sperm needs more study, the authors add. The results reaffirm that lubricants and oils are not alike, so each one must be carefully judged for its effect on fertility. They also warn that a lubricant that cuts motility should not be used as birth control.

RRM Context

Couples practicing fertility awareness-based methods time sex to the fertile days they chart. Lubricant choice matters during those days. This lab study adds data on how common lubricants and oils act on sperm. Pre-Seed, sold as a fertility-friendly lubricant, was the only commercial lubricant tested that did not impair motility, matching earlier studies the authors cite.

Abstract

Objective

To evaluate the effects of coital lubricants and oils on sperm motility.

Design

Comparative prospective in vitro study.

Setting

University Andrology laboratory.

Patients

Twenty-two normozoospermic donors.

Interventions

Semen samples were incubated in modified human tubal fluid (mHTF) control and in 10% Pre-Seed, Astroglide, and KY products (Sensitive, Warming, and Tingling) and baby, canola, sesame, and mustard oils. Total and progressive sperm motility was evaluated before and at 5, 30, and 60 minutes of incubation.

Main Outcome Measures

Sperm motility.

Results

Control samples exhibited no significant decrease in sperm motility. Pre-Seed showed a slight (∼4%) but significant drop in progressive motility after 30 minutes. Total and progressive sperm motility significantly declined under Astroglide, KY products (Sensitive, Warming, and Tingling) and sesame oil incubation. Canola oil significantly decreased total motility after 30 minutes and progressive motility after 5 minutes of incubation. Similarly, baby oil decreased total motility after 60 minutes and progressive motility after 5 minutes. After initial decline, total and progressive sperm motility under Pre-Seed and canola and baby oils remained high. Exposure to mustard oil caused persistent hyperactivation of sperm in each sample with no decrease in motility.

Conclusions

Sesame oil and synthetic coital lubricants impaired sperm motility and may hamper fertility. Pre-Seed and canola, mustard, and baby oils showed no deleterious effect and may be considered sperm-friendly coital lubricants. Mustard oil exposure resulted in hyperactivation of sperm and needs to be studied further.

Related research

Ranjit S Sandhu, Timothy H Wong, Crystal A Kling, Kazim R Chohan
R Sandhu, Tim Wong, T Wong, C Kling, K Chohan
PMID 24462060 24462060 DOI 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2013.12.024 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2013.12.024 Sandhu et al. 2014, Sandhu 2014