Birth and Delivery Birth Outcomes

Uterine scar rupture - Prediction, prevention, diagnosis, and management

Tanos V, Toney ZA

Published August 2019 Best Practice & Research. Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 59, 115-131
DOI 10.1016/j.bpobgyn.2019.01.009 PMID 30837118

RRM Academy Synopsis

Uterine rupture is likelier in VBAC after two cesareans than after one

A 2019 clinical article reports that women attempting vaginal birth after cesarean had more uterine rupture after two earlier cesareans than after one. Vaginal birth succeeded in 60% to 77% of women in the largest studies. The authors link a scar niche to later infertility.

Key Findings

  • Trial of labor after cesarean and vaginal delivery succeeded in between 60% and 77% of women in the largest studies.
  • Uterine rupture occurred in 1.59% of women with two earlier cesareans (VBAC-2) and 0.72% of women with one (VBAC-1).
  • Cesarean hysterectomy occurred in 0.56% of VBAC-2 women and 0.19% of VBAC-1 women.
  • Successful vaginal birth was more likely when the interpregnancy interval was less than 6.3 years and the interdelivery interval was less than 24 months.
  • The authors state that a niche (isthmocele) with under 3 mm or 2.5 mm of remaining muscle wall on ultrasound can be repaired surgically, to prevent rupture in a later pregnancy.

Interpretation

This synopsis rests on the published abstract of the article. The authors review earlier studies, so the figures come from that research. The abstract reports no difference between ways of closing the uterine incision in the results of a trial of labor. The abstract also reports no firm evidence that any thread type, knot or suturing order lowers rupture risk after VBAC or after uterine surgery for myomectomy. Three professional societies publish VBAC guidelines, and the authors note that none describes the surgical steps that lower rupture risk.

RRM Context

RRM looks for the physical cause of low fertility. The article names a cesarean scar niche as one such cause of secondary infertility. Repair by hysteroscopy or laparoscopy depends on the thickness of the remaining muscle wall on ultrasound.

Abstract

The increasing rate of elective and indicated caesarean sections worldwide has led to new pathologies and management challenges. The number of patients undergoing trial of labor after caesarean section (TOLAC) is also increasing. Three professional societies provide detailed guidelines based on scientific evidence for the management of patients attempting vaginal birth after caesarean section (VBAC). However, they do not provide any recommendations for the actual surgical steps to be followed to minimize the risks of uterine rupture (UR) during TOLAC. Uterine scar condition, intrapartum management and maternal health status correlate to uterine scar rupture risk and provide guidance for parturient TOLAC eligibility. TOLAC and vaginal delivery success rate as reported by the largest studies is between 60% and 77%. Uterine rupture is more prevalent in VBAC-2 patients (1.59%) in contrast to VBAC-1 (0.72%). Additionally, VBAC-2 patients have higher incidence of caesarean hysterectomy 0.56% vs. 0.19% for VBAC-1. The chances of successful VBAC increase when the interpregnancy/interdelivery interval is less than 6.3 years and less than 24 months, respectively. No difference was detected between the techniques of uterine incision closure of the previous CS and TOLAC results, although closure of the CS uterine incision in 2 layers seems to be practiced more widely. Niche or isthmocele presents another complication of CS. Secondary infertility due to niche, will eventually direct to hysteroscopic or laparoscopic repair, depending on the residual myometrial thickness (RMT) as measured by US scan. When RMT is below 3 mm or 2.5 mm surgery can be performed, to prevent any spontaneous UR in case of pregnancy. Monitoring by US scanning of hysterotomy scar after myomectomy can detect hematoma. In patients with severe postoperative pain but hemodynamically stable follow up by US scan examination can direct the management decision. In those patients with active bleeding and deterioration of hysterotomy scar edema will be an indication to surgery. There is no firm evidence regarding which type of thread, knotting or sequence of suturing is more favorable to reduce the risk of UR after VBAC or hysterotomy after myomectomy.

Read the guide

Topics

Related research

Birth and Delivery › Birth Outcomes › Maternal Morbidity · Uterine and Pelvic Conditions › Acquired Uterine Conditions › Cesarean Scar Defect
Vasilios Tanos, Zara Abigail Toney
V Tanos, Z Toney
PMID 30837118 30837118 DOI 10.1016/j.bpobgyn.2019.01.009 10.1016/j.bpobgyn.2019.01.009 Tanos et al. 2019, Tanos 2019