Lifestyle and Environment · Nutrition and Metabolic Health

Vitamin A: biomarkers of nutrition for development

Tanumihardjo SA

Published August 2011 The American journal of clinical nutrition, 94(2), 658S-65S
DOI 10.3945/ajcn.110.005777 PMID 21715511

RRM Academy Synopsis

Vitamin A blood tests can miss low liver reserves, a review finds

A 2011 brief review of vitamin A tests in people and animals reports that blood retinol stays steady until the liver's vitamin A stores run dangerously low. Dose-response tests and isotope dilution assays track those stores more closely. Liver stores are the gold standard, but measuring them directly is not feasible in human studies.

Key Findings

  • Liver reserves are the gold standard for vitamin A status, and measuring them directly is not feasible in human studies.
  • The World Health Organization lists 45 countries with a clinical-level public health problem and 122 countries with subclinical depletion and marginal liver reserves.
  • In a study of 309 Indonesian children, serum retinol did not differ between supplemented and unsupplemented groups 3–4 wk after supplementation.
  • In rural lactating women in Ghana, the dose-response (MRDR) test showed improved vitamin A status after supplementation (P < 0.0001), while serum retinol did not differ (P = 0.87).
  • After sugar fortification in Nicaragua, 9 of 21 children had calculated liver vitamin A concentrations above a level defined as toxic in 1990.

Interpretation

The paper is a brief review by one author. It describes vitamin A tests in humans, rats, piglets and monkeys. The human data come mostly from children, with some from lactating and pregnant women, in several countries. Validation against liver reserves came from rats, piglets and monkeys, and from liver biopsies in humans in the United States and Bangladesh. The author states that few human data exist on subtoxic or toxic vitamin A status.

RRM Context

The review lists reproduction among the functions of vitamin A. Its central point is that one blood value can look normal while stores run low. Restorative reproductive medicine looks for the underlying cause before judging that nothing is wrong, and that principle applies to nutrient status as well.

Abstract

Vitamin A is essential for multiple functions in mammals. Without vitamin A, mammals cannot grow, reproduce, or fight off disease. Because of its numerous functions in humans, biomarkers of vitamin A status are quite diverse. Assessment of liver reserves of vitamin A is considered the gold standard because the liver is the major storage organ. However, this measure is not feasible in human studies. Alternative biomarkers of status can be classified as biological, functional, histologic, and biochemical. Historically, signs of xerophthalmia were used to determine vitamin A deficiency. Before overt clinical damage to the eye, individuals who suffer from vitamin A deficiency are plagued by night blindness and longer vision-restoration times. These types of assessments require large population-based evaluations. Therefore, surrogate biochemical measures of vitamin A status, as defined by liver reserves, have been developed. Serum retinol concentrations are a common method used to evaluate vitamin A deficiency. Serum retinol concentrations are homeostatically controlled until liver reserves are dangerously low. Therefore, other biochemical methods that respond to liver reserves in the marginal category were developed. These included dose-response tests and isotope dilution assays. Dose-response tests work on the principle that apo-retinol-binding protein builds up in the liver as liver reserves become depleted. A challenge dose of vitamin A binds to this protein, and serum concentrations increase within a few hours if liver vitamin A concentrations are low. Isotope dilution assays use stable isotopes as tracers of total body reserves of vitamin A and evaluate a wide range of liver reserves. Resources available and study objectives often dictate the choice of a biomarker.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Lifestyle and Environment › Nutrition and Metabolic Health › Micronutrients and Supplements
Sherry A Tanumihardjo
S Tanumihardjo
PMID 21715511 21715511 DOI 10.3945/ajcn.110.005777 10.3945/ajcn.110.005777 Tanumihardjo et al. 2011, Tanumihardjo 2011