Restorative Reproductive Medicine Restorative Care and Assisted Reproduction

Assisted reproductive techniques and NaProTechnology

Dowbór-Dzwonka A, Cegła B, Filanowicz M, Szymkiewicz E

Published July 2012 Zdrowie publiczne, 122(3), 322-328
DOI 10.12923/j.0044-2011/122/3/a.19

RRM Academy Synopsis

IVF pregnancy rates fall with age in a Polish review of IVF and NaPro

A 2012 Polish narrative review of IVF and NaProTechnology cites age data showing IVF pregnancy rates fall from about 4 to about 1 out of 10 with age. It also describes the NaProTechnology workup, which pairs Creighton cycle charting with a full evaluation of both partners.

Key Findings

  • The review cites IVF pregnancy rates by age: 38.7% under 30, 33.1% at 31 to 35, 24.1% at 36 to 40, and 10.1% over 40.
  • The authors list IVF burdens: frequent visits, many tests, medicines with side effects, an invasive egg retrieval under general anesthesia, and risks including hyperstimulation syndrome and multiple pregnancy.
  • The authors report that in Poland patients pay the full cost of the IVF procedure and its medicines.
  • The authors describe NaProTechnology as cycle charting by both partners, usually for 3 to 6 months. An extended workup of about another half year follows, then treatment averaging about one year.
  • The authors conclude that each concept has limitations and costs, that their areas of interest and results mostly diverge, and that both can coexist.

Interpretation

This is a narrative review by nursing and midwifery faculty at Collegium Medicum in Bydgoszcz. The review reports no new patient data. The age-specific IVF figures come from a secondary Polish source, and the paper compares no outcomes between the two approaches. The authors write that naming a diagnosis does not ensure recovery. Their setting is Poland, where they note a lack of legislation on infertility care.

RRM Context

The review records the charge NaProTechnology practitioners make against IVF. In their view, IVF does not look for the cause of infertility, so it does not remove it. Restorative reproductive medicine evaluates both partners and treats the underlying cause, the step IVF bypasses. Outcome cohorts for restorative care have been published since 2012.

Abstract

Infertility is a significant and constantly increasing individual and social problem. It is estimated that at present it affects approx. 15 to 20 percent of couples. Inability to conceive a child elicits a range of unfavourable implications in the scope of emotional experiences, in the partner’s relationship and in a broader social perspective. Making a decision on undergoing diagnostics and infertility treatment is a difficult and often postponed moment for many couples. This is an expression of the escape model of dealing with a situation that threatens with a fall of self-esteem. However, if a couple reacts in a task-oriented way and participates in the diagnostic and therapeutic procedure, new doubts appear connected with the medical, psychological, social and ethical sphere. Infertility treatment sometimes prompts fear connected with the stripping of intimacy, loss of control over one’s body, possible complications and unsuccessful therapy. This article is an analysis of the medical and the other aspects of struggling with infertility with reference to two extremely different methods of solving this problem: NaProTechnology as a process of assisting natural procreation and assisted reproductive techniques with a special consideration of in vitro fertilization.

Read the guide

Topics

Related research

Restorative Reproductive Medicine › Restorative Care and Assisted Reproduction › Outcome Comparisons · Ethics and Policy › Reproductive Ethics › Embryo Status · Assisted Reproduction › Procedures and Protocols › IVF Protocols
Aneta Dowbór-Dzwonka, Bernadeta Cegła, Małgorzata Filanowicz, Ewa Szymkiewicz
A Dowbór-Dzwonka, B Cegła, M Filanowicz, E Szymkiewicz
DOI 10.12923/j.0044-2011/122/3/a.19 10.12923/j.0044-2011/122/3/a.19 Dowbór-Dzwonka et al. 2012, Dowbór-Dzwonka 2012