Assisted Reproduction Procedures and Protocols

From Eugenics to IVF Procedure

Original title (Polish) Od eugeniki do procedury zapłodnienia in vitro

Gruszka MJ

Published September 30, 2015 Seminare. Poszukiwania naukowe, 2015(36)(nr 3), 55-68
DOI 10.21852/sem.2015.3.05

RRM Academy Synopsis

A Philosophy Essay Links IVF's Embryo Selection to Eugenics History

A 2015 philosophy essay in the Polish journal Seminare argues that IVF grew out of eugenic thinking. The essay links embryo selection, freezing, and discarding back to that history. The author says NaProTechnology supports or restores the patient's natural cycle while excluding contraception and IVF, and offers it as common ground for both sides of the IVF debate.

Key Findings

  • The essay traces the word "eugenics" to Francis Galton in 1883 and follows the idea through Nazi-era genetic research to its post-war rebranding as "genetics" and "birth control."
  • Citing a Polish hospital study, the essay reports ovarian hyperstimulation needing hospital care in 35 of 678 IVF cycles, or 5.2%.
  • The essay cites a 2014 ESHRE meeting report that more than 5 million children have been born worldwide from IVF and related methods since 1978.
  • Citing a 2011 film, the essay says more than 500,000 frozen embryos sat in storage in the U.S.; a Polish source it cites says about half survive thawing well enough to transfer.
  • The essay reports that, as of 2014, nine doctors and twenty-four Creighton Model instructors practiced NaProTechnology in Poland, citing live-birth success at 44% to 80% depending on the cause of infertility.

Interpretation

The essay makes a philosophical and bioethical argument. The author draws on published medical, legal, and ethical sources, a 2011 film, and the writings of several bioethicists to build a historical case linking IVF to eugenics. The essay's account of IVF's steps and of NaProTechnology summarizes other authors' published work. The essay presents no new data of its own. The essay appeared in Seminare, a Polish journal of Catholic theology and philosophy. Its argument reflects that tradition's view of life from conception.

RRM Context

The essay places NaProTechnology within restorative reproductive medicine. This field looks for the specific cause of infertility in each partner, often through cycle charting, and treats it. The essay's claim that IVF builds in embryo selection and freezing matches a view raised elsewhere in bioethics writing on eugenics.

Abstract

In vitro fertilization (IVF) is a method known almost all over the world, by which modern man is trying to cope with the problem of infertility. The aim of this article is to show the eugenic roots of in vitro and to attempt to reconciliate the supporters and opponents of this controversial procedure at a NaProTechnological plane. In order to achieve this, the author characterizes IVF from the technical, medical and legal point of view. Then, the article shows the relationship between the in vitro procedure and eugenic thought. The third section contextualizes the problem of artificial insemination in the contemporary, human uncritical faith in technological progress. The last part of this article directs the reader's attention towards NaProTechnology – a method of infertility treatement which can engage both the supporters and the opponents of IVF.

Topics

Related research

Assisted Reproduction › Procedures and Protocols › IVF Protocols · Ethics and Policy › Reproductive Ethics › Embryo Status
DOI 10.21852/sem.2015.3.05 10.21852/sem.2015.3.05 Gruszka et al. 2015, Gruszka 2015