Fertility Awareness Effectiveness

Contraceptive failure of the ovulation method of periodic abstinence

Trussell J, Grummer-Strawn L

Published March 1990 Family Planning Perspectives, 22(2), 65-75
DOI 10.2307/2135511 PMID 2189750

RRM Academy Synopsis

Ovulation method first-year pregnancy 3.1% perfect, 86.4% imperfect

Critical to restorative reproductive medicine

The authors say the ovulation method is very effective if used perfectly, but extremely unforgiving of imperfect use. Among women in a World Health Organization trial, the first-year chance of pregnancy was 3.1 percent with perfect use. With imperfect use it was 86.4 percent.

Key Findings

  • The authors report a 3.1 percent chance of pregnancy in the first year of perfect use, which they call method failure.
  • The authors report an 86.4 percent chance of pregnancy in the first year of imperfect use, which they call user failure.
  • The authors say the pregnancy risk is highest when a woman breaks any of three rules: mucus days, the three days after peak fecundity, or times of stress.
  • The authors report a 28 percent risk of pregnancy per cycle when the most serious rules are broken.

Interpretation

Researchers reanalyzed results from a trial the World Health Organization ran to test the ovulation method, using a corrected statistical approach. The authors say earlier failure estimates for every birth control method were too low. They present their new numbers as the first correct ones. The authors also say everyday couples are likely to follow the method's rules less closely than the volunteers in this trial. Couples who break the strictest rules and avoid pregnancy once tend to take the same risk again. The findings support further study of how to help couples keep to the rules.

RRM Context

The ovulation method is a fertility awareness-based method based on reading signs of the fertile window. Restorative reproductive medicine shares that same charting base. It uses charting to find root causes and to guide evaluation before treatment. Named methods such as Creighton Model FertilityCare and NaProTechnology carry these ideas forward.

Abstract

Previously published estimates of probabilities of method and user failure for all contraceptive methods suffer from a serious methodological error and are biased downward, with the extent of bias unknown. Data from a World Health Organization clinical trial of the ovulation method of periodic abstinence were used to provide the first correctly calculated measures of method and user efficacy and to determine the characteristics that distinguish women who consciously take risks from those who do not. Probabilities of pregnancy during the first year are 3.1 percent during perfect use (method failure) and 86.4 percent during imperfect use (user failure). Thus, if used perfectly, the ovulation method is very effective. However, it is extremely unforgiving of imperfect use. Because perfect compliance is difficult for many couples who desire intercourse when it is forbidden by ovulation method rules, and because the risk of pregnancy during imperfect use is so great, the ovulation method cannot be considered an ideal contraceptive method for the typical couple, who are likely to be less compliant than couples who volunteer for a clinical trial. The probability of an accidental pregnancy is greatest when any of the three most serious rules--no intercourse during mucus days, within three days after the day of peak fecundity or during times of stress--are broken. Those who have a poor attitude toward the rules are more likely to take risks, including serious risks. Those who get away with taking a risk (i.e., do not get pregnant) are very likely to take risks again. Because breaking the most serious rules entails a 28 percent risk of pregnancy per cycle, those likely to take risks should be counseled about the probable consequences.

Read the guide

  • Fertility Awareness Methods Compared

    Clinician-reviewed comparison of fertility awareness-based methods (Billings, Creighton, Sensiplan, Marquette, Standard Days, apps). Every effectiveness figure cited and labeled by metric.

    30 min read

Topics

By this author

Related research

Fertility Awareness › Effectiveness › Typical and Perfect Use · Research Methods › Measurement and Statistics › Bias and Confounding
James Trussell, Laurence Grummer-Strawn
Jim Trussell, Jimmy Trussell, J Trussell, Larry Grummer-Strawn, L Grummer-Strawn
PMID 2189750 2189750 DOI 10.2307/2135511 10.2307/2135511 Trussell et al. 1990, Trussell 1990