Lynch, C. D., Simonsen, S. E., Stanford, J. B., & Mikolajczyk, R. T. (2010). Cumulative pregnancy probabilities among couples with subfertility: effects of varying treatments. Fertility and Sterility, 93(7), 2175-2181. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fertnstert.2009.01.080
Lynch CD, Simonsen SE, Stanford JB, Mikolajczyk RT. Cumulative pregnancy probabilities among couples with subfertility: effects of varying treatments. Fertil Steril. 2010;93(7):2175-2181. doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2009.01.080
Lynch, C. D., et al. "Cumulative pregnancy probabilities among couples with subfertility: effects of varying treatments." Fertility and Sterility, vol. 93, no. 7, 2010, pp. 2175-2181.
For EndNote, Zotero or Mendeley:
Open access
Free to read
No reuse license
Free to read at the publisher (reported by Unpaywall and OpenAlex, not verified by RRM Academy)
Simulated IVF speeds pregnancy, then regular intercourse catches up
In a simulation, early IVF led at first, then regular intercourse and conservative treatment caught up within 3 years. The model followed one million couples who were not pregnant after 2 years and had no clear diagnosis. Results rest on assumptions from published studies.
Study at a glance, simulation study of one million couples: Simulated IVF led at first, then other approaches caught up. Source: Lynch CD et al., 2009, PMID 19328479.
Key Findings
Each simulated cohort began with one million couples. Couples not pregnant after 2 years (26 cycles) entered five scenarios that ran for 3 more years (39 cycles).
In the model, IVF gave the highest cumulative pregnancy at first, and continuous conservative treatment overtook it at nine cycles.
In the model, relatively frequent intercourse alone overtook IVF at 28 cycles. Less frequent intercourse alone overtook no other scenario in 39 cycles.
In a second comparison, IVF begun after 20 cycles of conservative treatment gave the highest cumulative pregnancy at 26 cycles, roughly 2 years in.
At 1 year, the model gave spontaneous pregnancy of about 33% with frequent intercourse for couples with 2 years of failed trying, and about 20% with less frequent intercourse.
Interpretation
The study is a simulation. The authors fitted each couple's chance of conceiving to natural-fertility studies and took treatment effects from published literature. The findings describe the model and come from no trial of real couples. The IVF estimates came from a Netherlands cohort. There, couples without absolute indications for IVF must first receive other treatment. The authors say IVF results may be higher in couples without earlier treatment. Sensitivity analyses kept the same overall pattern. Aging during follow-up was left out.
RRM Context
The authors list NaProTechnology among other conservative approaches and say such treatments should be tested over longer periods. They also cite a randomized trial in which timing intercourse to the fertile window produced more pregnancies in couples with reduced fertility. Cumulative results show what a short window hides. IVF bypasses the causes of delay, while cause-based evaluation looks for them.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract
Objective
To model the cumulative probability of pregnancy among couples with subfertility without a definitive diagnosis, according to different treatment strategies.
Design
A beta distribution of fecundity was fitted that reproduced the cumulative probability of pregnancy in prospective studies of natural fertility, and this distribution was applied to simulated cohorts starting with one million couples each. Probabilities of pregnancy were generated for each cycle of each couple.
Setting
Simulation study.
Patients
Hypothetic subfertile population.
Interventions
After 2 or 4 years of attempting pregnancy and diagnostic evaluation to exclude anovulation, tubal obstruction, and severe male factor, simulated treatments were applied to the remaining nonpregnant couples, with treatment effects based on published literature.
Main Outcome Measures
Simulated cumulative probability of pregnancy.
Results
Initially, the cumulative probability of pregnancy was highest for early treatment with IVF, but over time, conservative treatment or frequent intercourse approached the same cumulative probability.
Conclusions
In couples without clear indications for IVF, the main benefit of early IVF may be to shorten time to pregnancy, a benefit that must be weighed against costs and potential adverse outcomes. Couples should be encouraged to maintain regular intercourse to maximize chances of pregnancy, even after unsuccessful treatment attempts.