Assisted Reproduction Donor Gametes and Surrogacy

Egg donation in the age of vitrification: A study of egg providers' perceptions and experiences in the UK, Belgium and Spain

Lafuente-Funes S, Weis C, Hudson N, Provoost V

Published February 2023 Sociology of health & illness
DOI 10.1111/1467-9566.13590 PMID 36444136 PMC PMC10100196

RRM Academy Synopsis

Egg providers appeared better informed in the UK than in Spain

Egg providers in the UK appeared better informed than those in Spain, according to interviews with 75 women who provided or offered eggs for IVF in the UK, Belgium and Spain. Belgian providers knew the egg count but little about recipients. Some Spanish providers voiced more suspicion of clinic motives than women in the UK or Belgium.

Key Findings

  • Researchers interviewed 75 egg providers between 2018 and 2020. The UK contributed 29 interviewees, Belgium 21 and Spain 25.
  • In the UK, the majority of providers were told the egg count on the day, by staff volunteering it or on request. In identity-release donation, they commonly knew their number of recipients.
  • In Belgium, most providers recalled hearing how many eggs were retrieved but had little precise information on how many recipients or cycles used them.
  • In Spain, most women could not recall being told how many eggs were retrieved. Six said staff had told them directly.
  • Most participants in all three countries opposed profit being made from eggs. Two thirds of Belgian women did not favor a clinic gaining extra money by passing eggs to another clinic.

Interpretation

This is a qualitative interview study, so the findings describe themes in what 75 women recalled and felt. The sample included women who volunteered but did not complete a cycle. Participants responded to calls circulated through social media, clinics, patient organizations and agencies. The Spanish group was younger on average (mean age 27.1 years, against 32.5 in the UK and 32.6 in Belgium). Most Belgian participants had given eggs anonymously, which the authors say may have shaped their experience. The authors propose that national regulation may explain some of the differences in information given. The article analyzes interviews with egg providers only.

RRM Context

Donor-egg IVF substitutes another woman's eggs and goes ahead without establishing why a couple's own conception fails. Restorative reproductive medicine starts with that question and evaluates both partners. The paper adds a third person, the egg provider, who undergoes ovarian stimulation and egg retrieval. Her information varied by country among the women interviewed.

Abstract

IVF treatment involving donated eggs increases yearly. Numerous technical and commercial transformations have reshaped how eggs are retrieved, stored and managed. A key transformation is vitrification; a 'fast freezing' method that allows efficient preservation of eggs, and therefore more flexibility in use, giving rise to new commercial possibilities. There has been limited focus on egg providers' experiences in the context of vitrification and related commercialisation. We report findings from a study in the UK, Spain and Belgium, where we interviewed 75 egg providers. Comparing experiences within different donation 'regimes' allows an exploration of how varying national practices and policies shape information-giving and women's experiences. In the UK, a system of 'informed gift-giving' was described, where egg providers saw their actions as not-for-profit and felt relatively well informed. In Belgium, the system was presented as 'trusted tissue exchange': with less information-giving than in the UK, but clinics were trusted to act responsibly. In Spain, a 'closed-door, market-driven' system was described, whereby egg providers received little information and expressed concerns about generation of excess profit. Our findings extend understandings of how egg donation is managed at the national level and how donation regimes produce specific experiences, expectations and subjectivities amongst tissue providers.

Topics

Related research

Assisted Reproduction › Donor Gametes and Surrogacy › Egg Donation · Ethics and Policy › Reproductive Ethics › Third Party Reproduction
Sara Lafuente-Funes, Christina Weis, Nicky Hudson, Veerle Provoost
S Lafuente-Funes, C Weis, N Hudson, V Provoost
PMID 36444136 36444136 DOI 10.1111/1467-9566.13590 10.1111/1467-9566.13590 Lafuente-Funes et al. 2023, Lafuente-Funes 2023