Fertility Awareness · Effectiveness

Fertility awareness methods and waiting conduct in idiopathic infertility: a prospective observational study

Barbato M, Del Zoppo S, Parazzini F, Graziani A, Guida M, Ferlin A, Frigerio L, Grande G

Published March 10, 2026 Frontiers in Reproductive Health
DOI 10.3389/frph.2026.1753325 PMID 41883420 PMC PMC13008926

RRM Academy Synopsis

21 of 41 couples with unexplained infertility conceived while charting

A multicenter prospective study of 97 couples with unexplained infertility followed 41 couples using fertility awareness methods, and about 5 out of 10 became pregnant within 12 months. Fewer than 2 out of 10 of the 56 couples who went straight to ART became pregnant. Among the 41, about 9 out of 10 women younger than 34 became pregnant.

Charting, 12 months 51.22%; IVF-type, one cycle 17.8%. Source: Barbato et al. 2026, PMID 41883420Charting, 12 months 51.22%; IVF-type, one cycle 17.8%. Source: Barbato et al. 2026, PMID 41883420PREGNANCY RATE, PER COUPLEUnexplained infertility, 41 vs 56 couplesCharting, 12 months51.22%IVF-type, one cycle17.8%Source: Barbato et al. 2026, PMID 41883420rrmacademy.org

Key Findings

  • In the fertility awareness group, 21 of 41 couples had a spontaneous pregnancy, a pregnancy rate of 51.22%, after 5.9 ± 3.9 months of observation.
  • In the ART group, 10 of 56 couples became pregnant (pregnancy rate 17.8%), counted over a complete ART cycle: all fresh and frozen-thawed embryo transfers from one episode of ovarian stimulation.
  • Within the fertility awareness group, the pregnancy rate was 90.9% (10 of 11 women) for women younger than 34 and 36.7% among the 30 women aged 35–39.
  • The authors report that this study observed no advantage of direct ART access over an additional year of waiting combined with fertility awareness methods in women younger than 40.

Interpretation

This prospective observational study ran at several centers from 2010 to 2014. The study compared 41 couples who learned the CAMeN symptothermal method with 56 couples who went straight to ART. Both partners in every couple had a diagnostic work-up, and the women were younger than 40 with a normal body mass index and apparently normal tubes and uterus. The authors note that the sample size is small. They suggest that couples whose complete evaluation ends in a diagnosis of unexplained infertility, especially younger couples, may wait an additional 12 months while using fertility awareness methods.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine treats unexplained infertility as a condition that has not yet been diagnosed, and it evaluates both partners. The paper cites a recent study in which only 8% of infertile couples stayed unexplained once both partners were fully studied. Fertility awareness methods fit this approach. Recording cervical mucus and basal body temperature shows the fertile window and works with the body's own cycle.

Abstract

Introduction

Couple infertility is a common clinical condition that is too often treated with assisted reproductive techniques (ARTs) without a proper evaluation of both male and female factors. To improve the likelihood of natural conception, fertility awareness methods (FAMs) are widely used.

Methods

We performed a multicenter prospective study enrolling couples with primary idiopathic infertility who were seeking natural conception. Participants were followed for 12 months using FAMs, and their outcomes were compared with those of couples who only used ARTs. The aim of our study was to evaluate the pregnancy rate after 12 months among couples with idiopathic infertility using FAMs compared with those who immediately pursued ARTs. We evaluated 41 couples in the FAM group and 56 couples in the ART group.

Results

In the FAM group, we reported a pregnancy rate (PR) of 51.22%. Among women aged <34 years, we reported a PR of 90.9%, while it decreased to 36.7% among women aged 35-39 years. In the ART group, 10 couples achieved pregnancy (PR 17.8%). Within this group, we reported a PR of 30% among women aged <34 years and 17.4% among women aged 35-39 years.

Discussion

After 12 months of unprotected intercourse without spontaneous conception in women younger than 35 years or after 6 months in women aged 35-39 years, couples should undergo a complete multidisciplinary diagnostic evaluation involving both the male and female partners. If a diagnosis of idiopathic infertility is established at the end of this process, couples (especially younger ones) may be advised to wait an additional 12 months while using FAMs, as no advantage has been observed with direct access to ARTs. They could then be referred to ART if a spontaneous pregnancy is not achieved during this period.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Fertility Awareness › Effectiveness › Comparative Effectiveness · Assisted Reproduction › Outcomes and Effectiveness › Outcomes by Diagnosis
Michele Barbato, Serena Del Zoppo, Fabio Parazzini, Andrea Graziani, Maurizio Guida, Alberto Ferlin, Luigi Frigerio, Giuseppe Grande
M Barbato, S Zoppo, F Parazzini, A Graziani, M Guida, A Ferlin, L Frigerio, G Grande
PMID 41883420 41883420 DOI 10.3389/frph.2026.1753325 10.3389/frph.2026.1753325 Barbato et al. 2026, Barbato 2026