Longevity and Reproductive Aging Lifespan Health

The sixth vital sign: what reproduction tells us about overall health. Proceedings from a NICHD/CDC workshop

Cedars MI, Taymans SE, DePaolo LV, Warner L, Moss SB, Eisenberg ML

Human reproduction open, 2017(2), hox008, 2017
DOI 10.1093/hropen/hox008 PMID 30895226 PMC PMC6276647

RRM Academy Synopsis

Infertility is associated with later heart disease and cancer

The report concludes that infertility in men and women is linked to later heart disease and cancer. It comes from an April 2016 workshop of about 40 experts on fertility and later health. Organizers summarized the workshop discussion.

Study at a glance, April 2016 workshop of about 40 experts: Infertility is linked to later heart disease and cancer
Study at a glance, April 2016 workshop of about 40 experts: Infertility is linked to later heart disease and cancer. Source: Cedars MI et al., 2017, PMID 30895226.

Key Findings

  • Workshop participants cite an incidence of ischemic heart disease about 60% higher in infertile men than in all other men.
  • Among 32 442 men followed for up to 32 years, those with low sperm concentration had 2.3 times the risk of testis cancer.
  • Studies of infertility and prostate cancer have found no association, a positive association, or a negative association, so the link is inconclusive.
  • The report says the evidence suggests four categories of possible biological explanation: genetic, hormonal, in utero, and lifestyle/health factors.
  • Participants agreed that a common working definition of infertility is a pressing need, and that it should include the infertile couple.

Interpretation

This report summarizes an April 2016 NICHD/CDC workshop. About 40 experts on fertility and later health took part. They reviewed evidence linking infertility in men and women to later heart disease and cancer. They also discussed genetic, hormonal, in utero, and lifestyle factors as possible biological pathways. The authors note that the direction of cause is not yet established. The findings support larger studies into how infertility relates to later disease risk.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine looks for the cause behind infertility before treatment starts. The workshop sees infertility as a possible early sign of chronic disease, which fits that approach. Its call to define infertility to include the couple fits couple-centered care.

Abstract

Study Question

Does the fertility status of an individual act as a biomarker for their future health?

Summary Answer

Data support an association between reproductive health and overall health for men and women.

What Is Known Already

Various chronic conditions, such as diabetes, obesity and cancer, can compromise fertility, but there are limited data for the converse situation, in which fertility status can influence or act as a marker for future health. Data reveal an association between infertility and incident cardiovascular disease and cancer in both men and women.

Study Design, Size, Duration

A National Institute of Child Health and Human Development-Centers for Disease Control and Prevention workshop in April 2016 was convened that brought together experts in both somatic diseases and conditions, and reproductive health. Goals of the workshop included obtaining information about the current state of the science linking fertility status and overall health, identifying potential gaps and barriers limiting progress in the field, and outlining the highest priorities to move the field forward.

Participants/Materials, Setting, Methods

Approximately 40 experts participated in the workshop.

Main Results and the Role of Chance

While the etiology remains uncertain for infertility, there is evidence for an association between male and female infertility and later health. The current body of evidence suggests four main categories for considering biological explanations: genetic factors, hormonal factors, in utero factors, and lifestyle/health factors. These categories would be key to include in future studies to develop a comprehensive and possibly standardized look at fertility status and overall health. Several themes emerged from the group discussion including strategies for maximizing use of existing resources and databases, the need for additional epidemiologic studies and public health surveillance, development of strategies to frame research so results could ultimately influence clinical practice, and the identification of short and long-term goals and the best means to achieve them.

Limitations, Reasons for Caution

Further research may not indicate an association between fertility status and overall health.

Wider Implications of the Findings

Currently medical care is compartmentalized. Reproductive medicine physicians treat patients for a short period of time before they transition to others for future care. Going forward, it is critical to take an interdisciplinary patient care approach that would involve experts in a broad range of medical specialties in order to more fully understand the complex interrelationships between fertility and overall health. If infertility is confirmed as an early marker of chronic disease then screening practices could be adjusted, as they are for patients with a family history of malignancy.

Study Funding/Competing Interests

Funding for the workshop was provided by the Fertility and Infertility Branch, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, National Institutes of Health and the Division of Reproductive Health, National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, Centers for Disease Control. There are no conflicts of interest to declare. The findings and conclusions in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention or the National Institutes of Health.

Trial Registration

Not applicable.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Longevity and Reproductive Aging › Lifespan Health › Cycle as a Lifespan Health Marker · General Gynecology › General Health › Cardiovascular Health
Marcelle I Cedars, Susan E Taymans, Louis V DePaolo, Lee Warner, Stuart B Moss, Michael L Eisenberg
M Cedars, Sue Taymans, S Taymans, L DePaolo, L Warner, S Moss, Mike Eisenberg, M Eisenberg
PMID 30895226 30895226 DOI 10.1093/hropen/hox008 10.1093/hropen/hox008 Cedars et al. 2017, Cedars 2017