Ethics and Policy Advocacy and Public Understanding

"Abortion myths and realities": who is misleading whom?

Cates W Jr

Published April 15, 1982 American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 142(8), 954-956
DOI 10.1016/0002-9378(82)90773-6 PMID 7072785

RRM Academy Synopsis

Cates argues legal abortion cut deaths of US women of reproductive age

Critical to restorative reproductive medicine

Cates argues that legal abortion measurably lowered deaths among American women of reproductive age. His 1982 paper replies to a physician's 1981 Senate testimony. Cates objects to how that testimony used national death data from 1940 to 1978.

Key Findings

  • Cates reports that an earlier 1975 testimony to an Australian commission drew criticism for its statistical extrapolation, mismatched data sets and choice of comparison intervals.
  • Cates states that the physician's 1981 testimony claimed legal abortion policy had no measurable benefit for maternal deaths and implied "natural pregnancy" was safer than induced abortion.
  • Cates gives six objections: risk in late pregnancy ignored, provisional 1978 data, poorly chosen states and intervals, the most appropriate references left out, relative frequencies, and abortion deaths merged into maternal deaths.
  • Cates reports that deaths linked to abortion of any type started falling faster than other pregnancy deaths in 1965, sped up in 1970, and generally kept falling through 1976.

Interpretation

This 1982 journal article rebuts Senate testimony on legal abortion and maternal deaths. Cates argues that deaths linked to abortion fell faster than other pregnancy deaths starting in 1965. The drop sped up in 1970 and kept going through 1976, a period when legal abortion access was expanding. The findings support further study of long-term mortality trends tied to abortion policy.

RRM Context

The paper addresses abortion death statistics. Restorative reproductive medicine centers on finding root causes before treating, on cycle charting, and on working with the body's own function. The abstract discusses none of these. The testimony it disputes is that of Dr. Thomas W. Hilgers, who developed NaProTechnology, and the dispute concerns how national data are analyzed.

Abstract

Thomas W. Hilgers, M.D., testifying to the Australian Royal Commission on Human Relationships in 1975, alleged that liberal abortions laws in the U.S. caused more deaths among women of childbearing age than they prevented. This inference was subsequently challenged because his analysis used a misleading extrapolation of linear regression, applied information from 2 incomparable data sets, and selected unreasonable item intervals for comparisons. On October 14, 1981, Hilgers testified before the U.S. Senate Subcommittee on the Constitution. He stated that America's legal abortion policy has had no measurable beneficial effect on maternal deaths and also implied that "natural pregnancy" was safer than induced abortion. These inferences were based on his recent analysis of abortion mortality with the use of national data from 1940 to 1978. Exception is still taken with Hilgers' inferences for the following reasons: neglect of risk associated with the last half of pregnancy; use of provisional 1978 data; selection of inappropriate states and time intervals; absence of the most appropriate references; use of relative frequency rather than absolute numbers; and aggregation of abortion mortality with maternal mortality. Contrary to the statements by Hilgers, the availability of legal abortion has had a measurable impact on deaths among American women of reproductive age. In 1965, even before the availability of legal abortion, deaths of women from all types of abortion (legal, illegal, and spontaneous) began to decline more rapidly than deaths from other pregnancy related causes. In 1970 the decline of abortion mortality rapidly accelerated and generally continued through 1976. In sum, legalized abortion has had a definite impact on the health of American women of childbearing age who are faced with unwanted pregnancies.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Ethics and Policy › Advocacy and Public Understanding › Public Awareness · Research Methods › Measurement and Statistics › Statistical Methods
Willard Cates Jr
W Cates
PMID 7072785 7072785 DOI 10.1016/0002-9378(82)90773-6 10.1016/0002-9378(82)90773-6 Cates Jr et al. 1982, Cates Jr 1982