Sonographic visualization of the cumulus oophorus or of morphologic alterations in the wall of the dominant follicle have been reported to be reliable signs of imminent ovulation when conventional transabdominal sonography is used. To determine if transvaginal sonography could allow a more frequent and confident prediction of imminent ovulation, we prospectively monitored 22 ovulatory menstrual cycles in four women undergoing artificial insemination and in 13 normally menstruating volunteers. Scanning was done on alternate days in the periovulatory period; a 7.5-MHz transvaginal transducer was used. Despite the improved resolution obtained with transvaginal sonography, confident identification of the cumulus oophorus or of mural changes in the follicle was not possible in any of the cycles followed. No other consistent follicular characteristic predicted imminent ovulation. We conclude that confident prediction of imminent ovulation is not possible with sonographic analysis.
PMID 2642364 2642364 DOI 10.2214/ajr.152.1.91 10.2214/ajr.152.1.91 Zandt-Stastny et al. 1989, Zandt-Stastny 1989
Cite this article
Zandt-Stastny, D., Thorsen, M. K., Middleton, W. D., Aiman, J., Zion, A., McAsey, M. E., & Harms, L. (1989). Inability of sonography to detect imminent ovulation. AJR. American journal of roentgenology, 152(1), 91-95. https://doi.org/10.2214/ajr.152.1.91
Zandt-Stastny D, Thorsen MK, Middleton WD, Aiman J, Zion A, McAsey ME, et al. Inability of sonography to detect imminent ovulation. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1989;152(1):91-95. doi:10.2214/ajr.152.1.91
Zandt-Stastny, D., et al. "Inability of sonography to detect imminent ovulation." AJR. American journal of roentgenology, vol. 152, no. 1, 1989, pp. 91-95.
The purpose of this pilot study was to correlate the three biologic markers of the Ovulon fertility monitor (a long-term predictive peak about 6 days before ovulation, a short-term predictive peak about 1 day before ovulation, and a nadir at the time of ovulation) with the peak in cervical mucus and the luteinizing hormone (LH) surge in the urine. Ten volunteer subjects (mean age 30.2 years) monitored their cervical-vaginal mucus, the surge of LH in the urine with a home assay test, and their vaginal electrical readings (with Ovulon monitors) on a daily basis for one to four menstrual cycles. In 19 of the 21 cycles that indicated a LH surge, there was a strong positive correlation between the LH surge and the peak of cervical-vaginal mucus (r = 0.96, P < or = .01), and between the LH surge and both the Ovulon nadir and Ovulon short-term predictive peak (r = 0.84, P < or = .01), and a modest positive correlation between the long-term Ovulon predictive peak and the LH surge (r = 0.62, P < or = .01). The time of optimal fertility as determined by the peak in cervical mucus, the LH surge, and the Ovulon was similar. The Ovulon has potential as a reusable device to help women determine their fertile period.
Ultrasonographic measurement of follicle growth and estradiol concentrations have been shown to correlate well in spontaneous and Clomid-induced ovulatory cycles. However, little is known about these changes during human menopausal gonadotropin (hMG) therapy. Twenty-five women who did not ovulate when treated with clomiphene were treated with hMG during 70 treatment cycles. Eleven patients had withdrawal bleeding after progesterone administration (group 1) and 14 did not bleed (group 2). Follicle growth was monitored with intermittent serum estrogen determinations and daily ovarian ultrasound with an ADR Model 2140 real-time sector scanner. The mean dominant follicle size at the time of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) injection was 21.2 mm +/- 0.6 (SEM) and was not different between the two groups. Mean serum estrogen level at the time of hCG injection was 1,121 pg/ml and correlated with follicle volume. At the time of hCG injection in group 2, one dominant follicle was present in 65% and two were present in 35% of the patients. Among those in group 1, two or more dominant follicles were present during all cycles. Mean serum estrogen levels were significantly higher in group 1 patients than those in group 2. This "chemical hyperstimulation" was induced in order to delay ovulation until adequate follicular size had been achieved. All cycles were ovulatory. Five patients in group 1 and eight in group 2 conceived. The use of ultrasound enables the physician to evaluate follicular growth and development daily and thus to individualize treatment and to reduce the need for estrogen monitoring.
Serial sonographic examinations were performed on 15 volunteers five days during the expected midcycle. The 75 sonographic studies were evaluated in a nonbiased manner, and the following features were assessed: 1) the presence or absence of a follicle within the ovary; 2) if present, the average dimension of the follicle; 3) the ability to delineate both ovaries; and 4) the presence of associated changes, such as involution of the follicle, echogenic texture within the follicle, or fluid in the cul-de-sac. The sonographic findings were correlated with serial leutinizing hormone (LH) assays as well as basal body temperature charts. As defined in the study, the correlation between the sonographic findings and hormonal determination were considered excellent in 70% of the cases, good in 20%, and poor in 10%. Both ovaries were delineated in 73% of the examinations performed, thus substantiating the ability of sonography to detect maturing ovarian follicles.
Healthy volunteers with regular ovarian function, women taking oral contraceptives, and infertile patients being treated with clomiphene were studied longitudinally from day 7 of the cycle to menstruation. The main objective was to determine whether ovulation or failure to ovulate could be detected accurately by the use of ultrasound. The ovaries were scanned with a Kretz Combison 100 sector scanner every 1 to 3 days for morphologic changes consistent with follicle development, ovulation, and development of the corpus luteum. The morphologic changes were correlated with daily urinary hormone profiles. The estimated times of ovulation according to ultrasound and luteinizing hormone peak overlapped by 24 hours in 19 of 23 normal cycles and in 5 of 6 cycles of patients treated with clomiphene. Both techniques indicated that three of three women taking oral contraceptives did not ovulate. The ultrasound studies indicated a wide range in the diameter of the preovulatory follicle, which precludes follicular diameter as a single index for prediction of ovulation. However, by measuring the maximal diameter of the follicle and observing the morphologic changes within the ovary from follicle to corpus luteum, it was possible to detect ovulation in more than 80% of cycles studied. This technique was found to be quick, inexpensive, and efficient.