Ethics and Policy Policy and Regulation

Information and misinformation on assisted human reproduction techniques in Europe: a normative analysis of the information provided on the websites of medically assisted reproduction clinics

Albert M, Tapia R, Farfán J, Vicente A, Muñoz S, Toribio-López M, Carrasco JM, De Bayas Sanchez A, Fuller M, Barrett N, Güell F

Published February 2, 2026 BMC medical ethics
DOI 10.1186/s12910-026-01388-5 PMID 41629892 PMC PMC12954940

RRM Academy Synopsis

Many European fertility clinic websites omit key facts on outcomes

Many European fertility clinic websites left out key facts on success rates and risks, a legal and ethics review of clinics in eight countries found. Researchers checked nearly 2000 pages against advertising law. Many success figures omitted what counted as success. Risks to babies got almost no mention.

Study at a glance, legal and ethics review: Many European clinic websites left out key facts on success rates and risks
Study at a glance, legal and ethics review: Many European clinic websites left out key facts on success rates and risks. Source: Albert M et al., 2026, PMID 41629892.

Key Findings

  • Many clinics blurred a positive pregnancy test, a clinical pregnancy and a live birth. Where they separated them, success was frequently given as pregnancy and rarely as live birth.
  • Two clinics reported different success rates for IVF with an embryo that had not been frozen: 65.1% in Spain and 28% in Slovenia.
  • A clinic in North Macedonia said IVF success rates beat natural pregnancy, yet listed a live birth rate of 26% against 30% for natural conception.
  • Only two clinics addressed risks to newborns directly, and none offered detailed data or long-term studies on the health of children.
  • Practically all clinics offered add-ons lacking scientific support, most often PGT-A. None explicitly acknowledged the lack of consensus on their effectiveness.

Interpretation

This study analyzed clinic website text from eight European countries. Researchers collected the pages from June to August 2023. They checked the text against advertising and consumer protection law. They also checked it against facts they call essential for patients. Clinics gave no patient information sheets or consent forms when asked. The authors recommend defining success as a healthy child. The findings support wider legal reviews of fertility clinic advertising across Europe.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine starts by asking why conception has not happened. IVF bypasses that question. Patients often rely on clinic websites to decide on treatment. This paper found many fertility clinic sites leave out clear facts on outcomes and risks. Patients need those facts to choose a path of care.

Abstract

Background

As part of the European Be better informed about Fertility project (B2-InF), we carried out a normative analysis of the information provided online by assisted reproduction clinics to the European public. This analysis aimed to determine the degree to which this information complies with regulations of medically assisted reproduction (MAR) and commercial information, and the main ethical implications related to the duty of information.

Methods

Information was gathered from the websites of 33 clinics across 8 European countries (Albania, Belgium, Spain, Italy, Kosovo, Northern Macedonia, Slovenia, Switzerland). Nearly 2000 pages of information were reviewed and checked for compliance with relevant frameworks of national and international law.

Results

The assessment revealed significant inconsistencies in how clinics present information online, with particular concerns regarding transparency about success rates, associated risks, add-on techniques and the legal and ethical issues that may arise during the use of these techniques.

Conclusions

The results of our analysis indicate an urgent need for enhanced regulatory oversight and standardized information requirements for assisted reproduction clinics across Europe. These findings suggest the necessity for harmonized legal frameworks that mandate comprehensive disclosure standards and establish effective enforcement mechanisms to ensure transparent and accurate information provision to potential patients.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Ethics and Policy › Policy and Regulation › Professional Standards
Marta Albert, Rosa Tapia, Juana Farfán, Alfonso Vicente, Sara Muñoz, María Toribio-López, Jose Miguel Carrasco, Anna De Bayas Sanchez, Michaela Fuller, Nathaniel Barrett, Francisco Güell
M Albert, R Tapia, J Farfán, A Vicente, S Muñoz, M Toribio-López, J Carrasco, A Sanchez, M Fuller, N Barrett, F Güell
PMID 41629892 41629892 DOI 10.1186/s12910-026-01388-5 10.1186/s12910-026-01388-5 Albert et al. 2026, Albert 2026