Restorative Reproductive Medicine · NaProTechnology

NaProTechnology (Natural Procreative Technology) - A Multifactorial Approach to the Chronic Problem of Infertility

Boyle PC, Stanford JB

Published March 17, 2011 Biomedicina (Sveikatos Mokslai/Health Sciences), 21, 61-68 Read at source
Read our synopsis

RRM Academy Synopsis

Three couples with failed IVF each had a baby after NaProTechnology

Three couples with failed IVF each had a baby after NaProTechnology care, a 2011 case series from one Galway clinic. The women were 37 to 41 when they came. Each couple had several diagnoses, treated together. The authors argue that infertility is usually chronic and has multiple causes.

Key Findings

  • A woman aged 41 and a man aged 40, after 3 failed IUI and 2 failed IVF, conceived when she was 42 and had a healthy baby boy (Case A).
  • A couple trying for 7 years, with polycystic ovaries, 3 failed IVF cycles and 1 frozen transfer, conceived on the fifth treatment cycle and had a healthy baby boy (Case B).
  • A couple both aged 38, with 12 cycles of ovulation induction, 3 IUI and 3 failed IVF behind them, had a healthy baby boy and conceived again in 2010 (Case C).
  • The evaluation found five diagnoses in Case A, four in Case B and five in Case C, and treatment targeted all of them together.

Interpretation

The paper is a retrospective case series: three couples from one clinic, reported by the treating clinic with a university co-author. The series reports one live birth after this care in each of three couples with earlier failed IVF. The paper gives no count of couples treated, no comparison group, and no way to tell which treatment step mattered. The second pregnancy in Case C was still ongoing at publication. The authors call for larger prospective cohort studies of couples with similar characteristics.

RRM Context

The authors treat infertility as a sign of underlying conditions. That reading makes unexplained infertility an undiagnosed condition. NaProTechnology, the method used here, times tests from the woman's Creighton Model FertilityCare chart. The authors cite a 2005 Cochrane review: IVF's effectiveness against other options for unexplained infertility remains unproven. In each couple, IVF came before the added diagnoses were found.

Abstract

Description

Infertility is usually a consequence of multiple chronic conditions rather than a single acute condition. We propose that it is erroneous to apply acute medical interventions to a condition that is chronic in nature.

Method

Retrospective analysis of 3 case studies which demonstrate the multifactorial and chronic nature of infertility that were previously managed unsuccessfully with acute intervention using IVF (in Vitro Fertilisation) or ART (Assisted Reproductive Technology).

Results

Demonstration of the multifactorial approach and 3 successful singleton live births using NPT (Natural Procreative Technology or NaProTechnology).

Conclusion

Infertility can be treated successfully with a multifactorial approach which takes into account the chronic nature of infertility and targets treatment to manage multiple factors responsible for the condition.

Discussion

Infertility is not a diagnosis but is often the expression of several underlying ill health conditions which if diagnosed and treated correctly will result in restoration of normal reproductive function. Physicians ought to consider broader diagnostic possibilities in their evaluation of infertile couples. A multifactorial treatment strategy for the chronic condition of infertility may be more effective than the widespread acute strategy employed by ART. Further study is required to investigate this possibility in more detail. Future studies looking at NPT and ART outcomes must be cohort studies comparing populations with similar patient characteristics.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Restorative Reproductive Medicine › NaProTechnology › Protocols and Framework · Assisted Reproduction › Outcomes and Effectiveness › Live Birth Rates
Phil C Boyle, Joseph B Stanford
Philip Boyle, Phillip Boyle, P Boyle, Joe Stanford, Joey Stanford, J Stanford
Boyle et al. 2011, Boyle 2011

Cite this article

Boyle, P. C., & Stanford, J. B. (2011). NaProTechnology (Natural Procreative Technology) - A Multifactorial Approach to the Chronic Problem of Infertility. Biomedicina (Sveikatos Mokslai/Health Sciences), 21, 61-68.