Boyle, P. C., & Stanford, J. B. (2011). NaProTechnology (Natural Procreative Technology) - A Multifactorial Approach to the Chronic Problem of Infertility. Biomedicina (Sveikatos Mokslai/Health Sciences), 21, 61-68.
Boyle PC, Stanford JB. NaProTechnology (Natural Procreative Technology) - A Multifactorial Approach to the Chronic Problem of Infertility. Biomedicina (Sveikatos Mokslai/Health Sciences). 2011;21:61-68.
Boyle, P. C., and J. B. Stanford. "NaProTechnology (Natural Procreative Technology) - A Multifactorial Approach to the Chronic Problem of Infertility." Biomedicina (Sveikatos Mokslai/Health Sciences), vol. 21, 2011, pp. 61-68.
Three couples had live births with NaProTechnology after failed IVF
In a retrospective case series, three couples whose IVF cycles had failed had three singleton live births under NaProTechnology. The authors propose that infertility is a chronic condition with several causes that responds better to several sustained interventions. Each couple's evaluation found multiple diagnoses, and the authors targeted treatment to those diagnoses.
Key Findings
Three couples, with women aged 41, 37 and 38 and earlier IVF cycles that ended without a live birth, had 3 successful singleton live births after NaProTechnology.
Each couple received several diagnoses: five in Case A, four in Case B and five in Case C. All three women had clinical endorphin deficiency and low progesterone.
The woman in Case A conceived at age 42, 1 year after first contact with the clinic. The woman in Case B conceived on her 5th cycle of treatment.
The couple in Case C had a healthy baby, then conceived again with the same approach, with an estimated date of delivery of 19th May 2011.
The authors' comparison lists twins at 4.5% after NPT against more than 20% after ART, and low birth weight at below 5% against 30%.
Interpretation
The paper is a retrospective case series of three couples, each with earlier IVF cycles that ended without a live birth. The cases illustrate infertility as a multifactorial condition, meaning one with several contributing causes. The authors state that cohort studies, which track outcomes over time, are the appropriate evidence for a chronic illness. They call for larger prospective cohorts of similar patients that report live birth outcomes. They also observe that registries in the UK, Europe and the USA record treatment cycles, so the number of women treated is unknown.
RRM Context
Restorative reproductive medicine (RRM) regards infertility as a symptom of underlying conditions that evaluation can identify and treatment can correct. NaProTechnology, developed by Dr. Thomas W. Hilgers, applies this principle by using the Creighton Model FertilityCare System to time investigations and by evaluating both partners. IVF proceeds without establishing why conception has not occurred.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract
Description
Infertility is usually a consequence of multiple chronic conditions rather than a single acute condition. We propose that it is erroneous to apply acute medical interventions to a condition that is chronic in nature.
Method
Retrospective analysis of 3 case studies which demonstrate the multifactorial and chronic nature of infertility that were previously managed unsuccessfully with acute intervention using IVF (in Vitro Fertilisation) or ART (Assisted Reproductive Technology).
Results
Demonstration of the multifactorial approach and 3 successful singleton live births using NPT (Natural Procreative Technology or NaProTechnology).
Conclusion
Infertility can be treated successfully with a multifactorial approach which takes into account the chronic nature of infertility and targets treatment to manage multiple factors responsible for the condition.
Discussion
Infertility is not a diagnosis but is often the expression of several underlying ill health conditions which if diagnosed and treated correctly will result in restoration of normal reproductive function. Physicians ought to consider broader diagnostic possibilities in their evaluation of infertile couples. A multifactorial treatment strategy for the chronic condition of infertility may be more effective than the widespread acute strategy employed by ART. Further study is required to investigate this possibility in more detail. Future studies looking at NPT and ART outcomes must be cohort studies comparing populations with similar patient characteristics.
NaProTechnology diagnoses and treats the underlying conditions driving infertility, menstrual disorders, and early pregnancy loss. This guide covers how the method works, published outcomes data, how to find a qualified provider, and what to expect on cost and insurance.