Birth and Delivery Birth Outcomes

Systematic review of the incidence and consequences of uterine rupture in women with previous caesarean section

Guise JM, McDonagh MS, Osterweil P, Nygren P, Chan BK, Helfand M

Published July 3, 2004 BMJ (Clinical research ed.)
DOI 10.1136/bmj.329.7456.19 PMID 15231616 PMC PMC443444

RRM Academy Synopsis

Labor after a prior cesarean adds 2.7 symptomatic ruptures per 1000

A review of 21 fair-to-good studies of women with a prior cesarean found that labor added 2.7 symptomatic uterine ruptures per 1000 compared with a planned repeat cesarean. Rupture-related perinatal deaths and hysterectomies added a few cases per 10 000.

Key Findings

  • From 568 full-text articles, the reviewers found 71 potentially eligible studies and rated 21 of them at least fair in quality.
  • Compared with a planned repeat cesarean, labor added 2.7 (95% confidence interval 0.73 to 4.73) symptomatic ruptures per 1000.
  • For women attempting vaginal birth, rupture added 1.4 (0 to 9.8) perinatal deaths and 3.4 (0 to 12.6) hysterectomies per 10 000. No maternal deaths were related to rupture.
  • Asymptomatic ruptures occurred at 16 (5.4 to 28.4) per 1000 with labor and 13 (4.3 to 26.2) per 1000 with a planned repeat cesarean, a nonsignificant difference.
  • The authors estimate 370 (213 to 1370) planned repeat cesareans would prevent one symptomatic rupture.

Interpretation

The review pools observational studies. Only one retrospective and one prospective study compared symptomatic rupture between labor and a planned repeat cesarean. The authors note that one misclassified case in the smaller study, or five in the largest, would erase the difference in symptomatic rupture. The women had low transverse or unclassified scars. The studies came from developed countries. Studies defined rupture in different ways, so the reviewers sorted events into symptomatic and asymptomatic.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine values absolute numbers for every route of birth. A scarred uterus can rupture with or without labor. The authors report that for more than two thirds of women who ruptured, neither mother nor infant had severe health consequences.

Abstract

Objective

To evaluate the incidence and consequences of uterine rupture in women who have had a delivery by caesarean section.

Design

Systematic review.

Data Sources

Medline, HealthSTAR, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, Cochrane Controlled Trials Register, National Centre for Reviews and Dissemination, reference lists, and national experts. Studies in all languages were eligible if published in full.

Review Methods

Methodological quality was evaluated for each study by using criteria from the United States Preventive Services Task Force and the National Health Service Centre for Reviews and Dissemination. Uterine rupture was categorised as asymptomatic or symptomatic.

Results

We reviewed 568 full text articles to identify 71 potentially eligible studies, 21 of which were rated at least fair in quality. Compared with elective repeat caesarean delivery, trial of labour increased the risk of uterine rupture by 2.7 (95% confidence interval 0.73 to 4.73) per 1000 cases. No maternal deaths were related to rupture. For women attempting vaginal delivery, the additional risk of perinatal death from rupture of a uterine scar was 1.4 (0 to 9.8) per 10,000 and the additional risk of hysterectomy was 3.4 (0 to 12.6) per 10 000. The rates of asymptomatic uterine rupture in trial of labour and elective repeat caesarean did not differ significantly.

Conclusions

Although the literature on uterine rupture is imprecise and inconsistent, existing studies indicate that 370 (213 to 1370) elective caesarean deliveries would need to be performed to prevent one symptomatic uterine rupture.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Birth and Delivery › Birth Outcomes › Maternal Morbidity
Marian S McDonagh, Patricia Osterweil, Benjamin K S Chan, Mark Helfand
M McDonagh, Pat Osterweil, Trish Osterweil, P Osterweil, Ben Chan, B Chan, M Helfand
PMID 15231616 15231616 DOI 10.1136/bmj.329.7456.19 10.1136/bmj.329.7456.19 Guise JM; McDonagh MS; Osterweil P; Nygren P; Chan BK; Helfand et al. 2004, Guise JM; McDonagh MS; Osterweil P; Nygren P; Chan BK; Helfand 2004