Controversy still exists as to the proper therapy of luteal phase defects. Some advocate using drugs to improve follicular dynamics, e.g., clomiphene citrate, while others treat luteal phase defects with progesterone. The possibility exists that in some cases the luteal phase defect is secondary to failure to produce a mature follicle, the better drug then being an ovulation-inducing drug, e.g., clomiphene. However, if the follicle is mature, then progesterone may be the best treatment. We defined mature follicle as one between 18 and 24 mm while the serum estradiol (E2) level is over 200 pg/mL. The efficacy of exclusive P therapy was evaluated in 50 women, all with a minimum of 1 1/2 years infertility and with no obvious fertility problems other than luteal phase defect. Seventy percent of the women conceived within 6 months. The abortion rate was 14.7%. The average period of infertility was 2.8 years in the 35 patients who conceived within 6 months. These data suggest that determining the degree of follicular maturation by serum E2 and pelvic sonography plus excluding the luteinized unruptured follicle syndrome by pelvic sonography helps determine the proper therapy for luteal phase defect.
Check, J. H., & Adelson, H. G. (1987). The efficacy of progesterone in achieving successful pregnancy: II. In women with pure luteal phase defects. International journal of fertility, 32(2), 139-141.
Check JH, Adelson HG. The efficacy of progesterone in achieving successful pregnancy: II. In women with pure luteal phase defects. Int J Fertil. 1987;32(2):139-141.
Check, J. H., and H. G. Adelson. "The efficacy of progesterone in achieving successful pregnancy: II. In women with pure luteal phase defects." International journal of fertility, vol. 32, no. 2, 1987, pp. 139-141.
Two hundred seventy-four infertile patients and 43 women with two or more previous first-trimester abortions underwent a luteal function evaluation by basal body temperature, plasma progesterone, estradiol and prolactin determination, and endometrial biopsy (repeated in a later cycle when the first was defective). An endometrial luteal phase deficiency was detected in 37 (13.5%) of the infertility cases and in 14 (32.5%) of the patients with recurrent miscarriage. However, the endometrial defect was associated with normal hormonal levels in the great majority of patients (86.3%).
In some series the most appropriate therapy for luteal phase defects is supplemental progesterone in the luteal phase. Clomiphene's efficacy is more controversial since in one series only 8% achieved a successful pregnancy versus 45% in another study. Pelvic sonography was used to evaluate follicular development and release of the ovum in 50 infertile women with luteal phase defects. The results showed that only 40% had "pure" luteal phase defects whereas 52% had immature follicles and 8% had unruptured follicles. Sixty-two percent of the patients had previous therapy for a luteal phase defect and failed to conceive. Sixty-eight percent of this group did conceive when ultrasound was used to determine the appropriate therapy. Thus ultrasound can be employed to determine if the women with a luteal phase defect should be treated with a fertility drug, e.g., clomiphene or just with luteal phase progesterone support. Supplemental progesterone might still be needed with clomiphene based on repeat endometrial biopsy results.
Practice Committee of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine and Practice Committee of the Society for Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility, 2026·Fertility and sterility
Luteal phase deficiency (LPD) is a clinical diagnosis associated with abnormal luteal phase length of ≤10 days. Potential etiologies of LPD include inadequate progesterone duration, inadequate progesterone levels, or endometrial progesterone resistance. Luteal phase deficiency has been described in association with medical conditions, but also in fertile, normally menstruating women. Although progesterone is important for the process of implantation and early embryonic development, LPD has not been proven to be an independent entity causing infertility or recurrent pregnancy loss. Controversy exists regarding the multiple proposed measures for diagnosing LPD, and assuming it can be diagnosed accurately, whether treatment improves outcomes. This document replaces the document of the same name, last published in 2021 (Fertil Steril 2021;115(6):1416-23).