Gautray, J. P., de Brux, J., Tajchner, G., Robel, P., & Mouren, M. (1981). Clinical investigation of the menstrual cycle. III. Clinical, endometrial, and endocrine aspects of luteal defect. Fertility and Sterility, 35(3), 296-303. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0015-0282(16)45374-4
Gautray JP, de Brux J, Tajchner G, Robel P, Mouren M. Clinical investigation of the menstrual cycle. III. Clinical, endometrial, and endocrine aspects of luteal defect. Fertil Steril. 1981;35(3):296-303. doi:10.1016/s0015-0282(16)45374-4
Gautray, Jean Pierre, et al. "Clinical investigation of the menstrual cycle. III. Clinical, endometrial, and endocrine aspects of luteal defect." Fertility and Sterility, vol. 35, no. 3, 1981, pp. 296-303.
For EndNote, Zotero or Mendeley:
Open access
Free to read
No reuse license
Free to read at the publisher (reported by Unpaywall and OpenAlex, not verified by RRM Academy)
Women with luteal defect had lower progesterone and disturbed cycles
In a 1981 French clinic study, the 88 women with luteal defect had lower progesterone than the 79 normal cycles. The 88 came from 328 women with cycle problems or infertility, diagnosed by endometrial biopsy. Their temperature charts showed cycle disturbances such as late ovulation or a slow rise. The authors suggest a central origin.
Key Findings
Of 328 outpatients with menstrual disorders and/or infertility, 88 (26.8%) had luteal insufficiency on endometrial biopsy. The comparison group was 79 normal cycles.
Biopsy patterns sorted the 88 women into 41 with pure luteal defect and 47 with luteal insufficiency with persistent estrogenic influence.
Basal body temperature charts placed 29 cycles within the normal range for phase lengths and 59 outside it. All 29 showed a slow temperature rise.
Plasma progesterone and estradiol were lower than in normal cycles in both groups, particularly with persistent estrogenic influence. Days 5 to 8 after ovulation showed the most significant deficiency.
Receptors were measured in 41 endometrial samples. Estradiol receptor concentrations and nuclear progesterone receptor concentrations were lower than in normal cycles.
Interpretation
This 1981 case series followed clinic patients, with normal cycles as the comparison group. The study links luteal defect to lower progesterone, lower estradiol, and lower levels of endometrial hormone receptors. The authors suggest a central cause. The authors note they could not measure hormone signals from the brain. The findings support larger studies of hormone receptor patterns in luteal defect.
RRM Context
Cycle charts can show the pattern this study linked to luteal defect: late ovulation or a slow rise in temperature. Restorative reproductive medicine looks for the cause of a weak luteal phase. These women also had low progesterone, low estradiol, and abnormal patterns in the womb lining.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract
This study was intended to correlate different clinical and biologic parameters to better define luteal insufficiency (LI) and to contribute to a better understanding of its origin. Endometrial patterns were used as the basis for classification of clinical cases. Of 328 outpatients with menstrual disorders and/or infertility, 88 were considered to have LI. Their cycles were compared with 79 normal cycles. Two different principal endometrial patterns of LI are described: pure LI, when the endometrium is more than 2 days out of phase; and LI with persistent estrogenic influence, when the histologic estrogenic stigmata are excessive during the luteal phase. Basal body temperature charts demonstrated menstrual cycle disturbances: either ovulation delay or a slow increase in temperature (longer than 2 days). Plasma steroid concentrations also demonstrated a perturbation of the entire menstrual cycle: progesterone levels were statistically significantly lower in LI than in normal cycles and this defect was worse when the estrogenic influence was persistent; the preovulatory estradiol peak was disturbed in all circumstances, as was the concentration of endometrial steroid receptors. These simultaneous abnormalities strongly suggest a central origin of LI.