Menstrual Cycle Cycle Biomarkers

Hormonal Predictors of Abnormal Luteal Phases in Normally Cycling Women

Abdulla SH, Bouchard TP, Leiva RA, Boyle P, Iwaz J, Ecochard R

Published June 9, 2018 Frontiers in Public Health, 6, 144
DOI 10.3389/fpubh.2018.00144 PMID 29881719 PMC PMC5978451

RRM Academy Synopsis

Long Preovulatory Phases Predict Short Luteal Phases in Normal Cycles

A long preovulatory phase predicted a short luteal phase among 99 regularly cycling women (266 cycles) at eight European clinics. A small largest follicle predicted a progesterone marker that started normal, then fell. Short luteal phases occurred in nearly 11 out of 100 cycles.

Study at a glance, Observational study: A long preovulatory phase predicted a short luteal phase
Study at a glance, Observational study of 99 regularly cycling women: A long preovulatory phase predicted a short luteal phase. Source: Abdulla SH et al., 2018, PMID 29881719.

Key Findings

  • Short luteal phases (fewer than 12 days) occurred in nearly 11% of the 266 cycles. A long preovulatory phase predicted them in these women, with or without adjustment for other variables.
  • A low mid-luteal PDG level occurred in 26% of cycles (69 cycles). A low periovulatory PDG level predicted it. So did a younger age at menarche and a high body mass index.
  • A normal then low luteal PDG pattern occurred in 12% of cycles (34 cycles). A small largest follicle predicted it, with or without adjustment for other variables.
  • A high periovulatory PDG level predicted both a short luteal phase and the normal then low pattern. The authors call these results rather strange and ask for confirmation by other studies.
  • A low then normal pattern occurred in 21% of cycles (54 cycles). A low periovulatory PDG level predicted it. The authors say it seems to be a sign of long luteinization.

Interpretation

This cohort study followed 99 regularly cycling women across 266 cycles at eight European clinics. The women had a low average body mass index. The study excluded women with infertility, women who often did not ovulate, and women with known abnormal cycles. The results link follicle growth before ovulation to progesterone patterns after ovulation, pointing to possible causes of short or low luteal phases in women with normal cycles. The authors note that some results were unexpected and call for confirmation. The findings support larger studies of these patterns.

RRM Context

The paper builds its outcome measures on the five luteal deficiency types developed by Dr. Thomas W. Hilgers within NaProTechnology, and extends them to borderline cases in normal cycles. Restorative reproductive medicine asks why a luteal phase falls short. The paper points toward follicle development before ovulation as part of the answer.

Abstract

Objective

Explore potential relationships between preovulatory, periovulatory, and luteal-phase characteristics in normally cycling women.

Design

Observational study.

Setting

Eight European natural family planning clinics.

Patients

Ninety-nine women contributing 266 menstrual cycles.

Interventions

The participants collected first morning urine samples that were analyzed for estrone-3 glucuronide (E1G), pregnanediol-3- alpha-glucuronide (PDG), follicle stimulating hormone (FSH), and luteinizing hormone (LH). The participants underwent serial ovarian ultrasound examinations.

Main Outcome Measures

Four outcome measures were analyzed: short luteal phase, low mid-luteal phase PDG level (mPDG), normal then low luteal PDG level, low then normal luteal PDG level.

Results

A long preovulatory phase was a predictor of short luteal phase, with or without adjustment for other variables. A high periovulatory PDG level was a predictor for short luteal phase as well as normal then low luteal PDG level. A low periovulatory PDG level predicted low mPDG and low then normal luteal PDG level, with or without adjustment for other variables. A small maximum follicle predicted normal then low luteal PDG level, with or without adjustment for other variables. The relationship between small maximum follicle size and short luteal phase or small maximum follicle size and low mPDG was no longer present when the regression was adjusted for certain characteristics. A younger age at menarche and a high body mass index were both predictors of low mPDG.

Conclusion

Luteal phase abnormalities exist over a spectrum where some ovulation disorders may exist as deviations from the normal ovulatory process.This study confirms the negative impact of a small follicle size on the quality of the luteal phase. The occurrence of normal then low luteal PDG level is confirmed as a potential sign of luteal phase abnormality.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Menstrual Cycle › Cycle Biomarkers › Hormonal Markers · Reproductive Endocrinology › Luteal Phase › Luteal Phase Deficiency · Fertility Awareness › Biomarkers › Urinary Hormone Monitoring
Saman H Abdulla, Thomas P Bouchard, Rene A Leiva, Phil Boyle, Jean Iwaz, René Ecochard
S Abdulla, Tom Bouchard, T Bouchard, R Leiva, Philip Boyle, Phillip Boyle, P Boyle, J Iwaz, R Ecochard
PMID 29881719 29881719 DOI 10.3389/fpubh.2018.00144 10.3389/fpubh.2018.00144 Abdulla et al. 2018, Abdulla 2018