KorrTra – a correlational study on basal body temperature

Makarova V, Frank-Herrmann P, Malliou-Becher MN

Published August 9, 2024 IIRRM 2024 Congress, Vancouver

RRM Academy Synopsis

Nightly sensor tracked Sensiplan within a day in 88% of cycles

In a preliminary prospective study of 43 experienced Sensiplan users, the nightly intravaginal sensor placed the last fertile day within one day of Sensiplan in 88 out of 100 cycles. The methods named the same day in 66 out of 100 cycles. The sensor ended the fertile phase earlier in 25 out of 100.

Key Findings

  • The analysis covered 302 cycles from 43 women, from a study that enrolled 51 experienced Sensiplan users aged 18 to 40 years (median age 28).
  • In the preliminary analysis, the last fertile day coincided in both methods in 66% of cycles.
  • In the preliminary analysis, the last fertile day agreed within +/- one day in 88% of cycles and within +/- two days in 96%.
  • In total 25% of trackle cycles showed an earlier last fertile day.
  • The Pearson correlation coefficient for the last fertile day was between 0.9 and 1.

Interpretation

KorrTra is a prospective single-center study from Heidelberg University Hospital. Experienced Sensiplan users applied the morning measurement and the nightly trackle sensor (a class IIb medical device) in parallel for 2 to 6 months. Both were evaluated by Sensiplan rules. Data collection was still ongoing, so the results are preliminary. The authors write that the deviation seems small but could still matter for people who depend on precise timing. They add that an earlier end of the fertile phase may sharpen tracking but could carry some risk for family planning efficacy. Trackle GmbH, the sensor's maker, funded the study.

RRM Context

Sensiplan is a symptothermal method of fertility awareness. It checks temperature against cervical mucus to find the fertile window. The study states that family planning apps should rest on evidence. Fertility awareness education holds any new tool to that same standard.

Abstract

The development of medical apps for fertility monitoring has increased in recent years. Mobile applications for family planning should be used based on evidence. This study examines the correlation of nightly intravaginal basal temperature measurement using the "trackle" sensor (medical device class IIb) as an alternative to the conventional morning measurement according to the symptothermal method "Sensiplan" (gold standard, symptothermal rules: double-check temperature with cervical mucus) [1]. METHODS/PROCEDURE KorrTra is a prospective monocentric study. Experienced "Sensiplan" users (n=51), aged 18-40 years years with a median age of 28, without hormonal contraception, pregnancy, or amenorrhea, were recruited. Both methods were applied in parallel for 2-6 months. The following variables were compared: the first higher measurement, the end of the temperature evaluation, and the last fertile day (LFRT, acc. to symptothermal rules: double-check temperature with cervical mucus). The temperature evaluation in both methods was carried out in accordance with the "Sensiplan"-method. Additionally, a case-by-case analysis was conducted when necessary. The ethics committee of the University of Heidelberg approved the procedure.

Outcome

Since the date collection is still ongoing, perliminary data (302 cycles from 43 women) collected up to 12/07/24 was analyzed. The LFRT coincided in sixty-six percent (66%) of cycles in both methodes ("Sensiplan" and "trackle"), whereas there was an 88% correlation within +/- one day and 96% correlation within +/- two days. In total 25% of trackle cyles showed an earlier LFTR. The Pearson correlation coefficient for the LFTR was between 0.9 and 1. [Figure: scatter plot of LFRT differences by index; example cycle monitored with "Sensiplan" (grey) and "trackle" (blue).] DISCUSSION/CONCLUSION 1. The findings contribute to the evolving landscape of fertility monitoring by evaluating the efficacy of nocturnal intravaginal temperature measurement. 2. The preliminary data suggest a strong correlation between both methods. Although the deviation in the LFRT determined by both methods seems to be small, it could be still relevant for individuals relying on precise dermination of the fertile phase for family planning. 3. Twenty-five percent of the cycles recorded with the intravaginal sensor showed an earlier end of the fertile phase. This could indicate that the post-ovulatory phase might be recognized earlier, which may enhance the precision of fertility tracking, but in some cases also potentially entail a certain risk regarding efficacy of family planning. 4. The case-by-case analysis, which is presently underway, aims to identify areas of strengths as well as vulnerability inherent in the trackle-system.

By this author

Related research

Makarova et al. 2024, Makarova 2024