Hopton, E. N., & Redwine, D. B. (2014). Eyes wide shut: the illusory tale of 'occult' microscopic endometriosis. Human Reproduction, 29(3), 384-387. https://doi.org/10.1093/humrep/det441
Hopton EN, Redwine DB. Eyes wide shut: the illusory tale of 'occult' microscopic endometriosis. Human Reproduction. 2014;29(3):384-387. doi:10.1093/humrep/det441
Hopton, Elizabeth Naomi, and David Byron Redwine. "Eyes wide shut: the illusory tale of 'occult' microscopic endometriosis." Human Reproduction, vol. 29, no. 3, 2014, pp. 384-387.
Occult microscopic endometriosis rates seem to track viewing distance
This is an invited commentary. The commentary answers a paper that found more hidden endometriosis. Earlier work that looked much closer up found far less. With enough magnification, the authors say, hidden disease nearly disappears.
Key Findings
Murphy et al. 1986 found microscopic endometriosis in normal-looking peritoneum in 25% of 20 patients. All 20 had open surgery for endometriosis. They looked at arm's length.
The paper under review viewed tissue from about 4 cm away. Earlier studies used less than 1 cm and found the finding far less often.
Tissue samples in the paper under review measured several centimeters across. Earlier near-contact studies used samples under 5 mm.
The paper's Type II category counted tissue as endometriosis without requiring glands. Every earlier study on this topic required both glands and stroma.
The authors conclude that most women with endometriosis do not carry invisible microscopic disease beyond what excision already removes.
Interpretation
This is an editorial commentary. No new patients were examined for it. The paper it answers used a farther viewing distance, bigger tissue samples, and a wider definition of endometriosis. The authors say this explains its higher reported rate. The commentary is expert opinion built on comparing published methods. No controlled study tested the methods side by side, so neither can be proven more accurate. The analysis covers only surgical detection during laparoscopy. The piece gives no findings on pain, fertility, or treatment outcomes; it raises these as open questions for future study. The authors and the paper they answer work in the same field but hold opposing views.
RRM Context
Restorative reproductive medicine favors full surgical removal of visible endometriosis. RRM does not favor treating a guessed pool of hidden disease with suppressive drugs. This piece backs that view. The authors say most women with endometriosis have no hidden microscopic disease. Careful excision should leave few overlooked foci. Small deposits inside the ovary are truly hidden, they add. The analysis does not cover how RRM clinicians handle infertility or pelvic pain beyond this one detection question.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Endometriosis is a chronic inflammatory disease that drives pain, organ dysfunction, and infertility. How RRM-trained clinicians diagnose and treat it through excision surgery, cycle charting, and longitudinal care.