Fertility Awareness Effectiveness

Fertility awareness-based methods of family planning: A review of effectiveness for avoiding pregnancy using SORT

Manhart MD, Duane M, Lind A, Sinai I, Golden-Tevald J

Published January 2013 Osteopathic Family Physician, 5(1), 2-8
DOI 10.1016/j.osfp.2012.09.002

RRM Academy Synopsis

Correct use of modern fertility awareness methods gave few pregnancies

In a 2013 review of 29 studies of modern fertility awareness-based methods (FABM), correct use gave 0.4 to 5.0 unintended pregnancies per 100 women years. The studies covered 8200 women across more than 107,000 cycles. The authors graded each study with the Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy (SORT).

Study at a glance, review of 29 studies of 8200 women: Correct use gave 0.4 to 5.0 unintended pregnancies per 100 women years
Study at a glance, review of 29 studies of 8200 women: Correct use gave 0.4 to 5.0 unintended pregnancies per 100 women years. Source: Manhart MD et al., 2013, DOI 10.1016/j.osfp.2012.09.002.

Key Findings

  • The search found 29 peer-reviewed clinical studies since 1980 on FABM for avoiding pregnancy. Every major FABM had at least 1 robust study (SORT evidence Level 1).
  • The best studies together involved 8200 women across over 107,000 cycles.
  • With correct use, the major FABM had 0.4-5.0 unintended pregnancies per 100 women years.
  • With typical use, the sympto-thermal method from European trials had 1-2 unintended pregnancies per 100 women years. Other FABM had 10-14 in more recent studies.
  • Sympto-thermal methods earned strength of recommendation A. Creighton earned A for correct use only. Billings, Marquette, Standard Days Method and TwoDay Method earned B.

Interpretation

A 2013 review graded 29 studies of modern fertility awareness methods. The authors used the Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy to grade each study. Older surveys put the pregnancy rate for fertility awareness methods at 25 per 100 woman years. The older surveys lumped together each method, including homemade versions not studied in medical journals. Findings support more research on fertility awareness methods across more diverse groups.

RRM Context

Cycle charting is a shared foundation of restorative reproductive medicine. The review says signs of ovulation mark good health. It adds that they can help diagnose and treat infertility and other gynecologic problems, citing two NaProTechnology practice series. The authors say family planning may be best discussed with the couple, since healthy men are generally fertile from puberty.

Abstract

Each year, over three-fourths of the women of reproductive age in the United States seek family planning services from primary care clinicians. Women and their doctors should be informed of all effective family planning options and their respective effects on a woman's reproductive health. Family physicians are well-trained to support the behavior choices necessary for the successful adoption of any reversible family planning method. However, many are unfamiliar with fertility awareness-based methods (FABM) of family planning or have misconceptions about their effectiveness, complexity, or suitability for their patients. FABM teach women to observe the physical signs and symptoms that follow hormonal fluctuations throughout the menstrual cycle to identify a couple's fertile window, which can be used to avoid or achieve pregnancy. One in 5 women in the United States expressed interest in using FABM when informed about such options. When correctly used to avoid pregnancy, modern FABM have unintended pregnancy rates<5 (per 100 women years). Studies of modern FABM show that their typical unintended pregnancy rates are comparable to those of commonly used contraceptives. This article presents a review of the FABM literature to (1) familiarize the reader with the physiological basis and features of modern FABM, (2) present and utilize a framework to evaluate clinical evidence using the Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy (SORT), which supports the effectiveness of modern FABM for avoiding pregnancy, and (3) serve as a resource for health care professionals offering FABM options to their patients.

Read the guide

Topics

By this author

Related research

Fertility Awareness › Effectiveness › Typical and Perfect Use
Michael D. Manhart, Marguerite Duane, April Lind, Irit Sinai, Jean Golden-Tevald
Mike Manhart, M Manhart, M Duane, A Lind, I Sinai, J Golden-Tevald
DOI 10.1016/j.osfp.2012.09.002 10.1016/j.osfp.2012.09.002 Manhart et al. 2013, Manhart 2013