Body Literacy Patient Education

"It always gets pushed aside:" Qualitative perspectives on puberty and menstruation education in U.S.A. schools

Schmitt ML, Gruer C, Hagstrom C, Ekua Adenu-Mensah N, Nowara A, Keeley K, Sommer M

Published October 21, 2022 Frontiers in Reproductive Health, 4
DOI 10.3389/frph.2022.1018217 PMC PMC9635341

RRM Academy Synopsis

Girls in big U.S. cities say school puberty lessons fall short

A qualitative study in Chicago, Los Angeles, and New York City found that girls and school staff described puberty and period lessons as uneven, unengaging, and short on practical content. Participants were Black and Latina girls aged 15 to 19 and adults who work with youth. Staff and girls also described parents leaning on schools to teach the topic.

Key Findings

  • The study drew on 7 participatory groups with 73 girls, 12 in-depth interviews with girls, and 23 interviews with adults, in three cities from October 2018 through March 2020.
  • Many school and nonprofit staff said parents rely too heavily on schools for puberty education. Girls described embarrassment and difficult family dynamics that kept the topic out of the home.
  • Girls and staff described teacher discomfort and little training. Physical education teachers, often men, were frequently assigned the lessons, and girls said they asked fewer questions of male teachers.
  • A middle school counselor said puberty lessons are not a priority because they are not part of testing. Girls described lessons that stressed biology and pregnancy over practical period management.
  • Several girls wanted to know what a normal period looks like and when to see a health provider. Many girls turned to internet searches to fill gaps.

Interpretation

The study is a qualitative study with participatory methods. The authors report themes from what girls and adults said. The participants were low-income girls aged 15 to 19 in three large cities, recalling earlier school years. The authors note that rural and suburban girls fall outside what the study can describe. They call for research on which teaching methods work best.

RRM Context

Several girls in this study wanted to know what a normal period looks like and when to see a provider. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists describes the menstrual cycle as a vital sign in adolescents. That idea depends on girls knowing their own patterns. Restorative reproductive medicine builds on body literacy, and these accounts show where early education leaves gaps.

Abstract

Adolescent girls in the U.S.A. often lack sufficient education on pubertal and menstrual health topics. This educational gap may be growing given the current decline in American elementary and middle schools' delivery of sexual health education. Furthermore, little is known about the actual scope and quality of existing menstruation and puberty education in U.S.A. schools. This paper provides insights into some of the challenges with the delivery of menstruation and puberty education in schools. Qualitative and participatory research methodologies were utilized with Black and Latina girls ages 15–19 and adults working with youth in three U.S.A. cities (Chicago, Los Angeles, and New York City), exploring experiences of menstruation within school and family contexts. Findings revealed tension between school responsibility and family authority in providing menstruation and puberty education in schools, school- and teacher-related delivery challenges, and inadequate and disengaging menstruation and puberty content. Further research is needed on the effectiveness and best practices for providing this education in schools, including improved understanding on student and parent preferences, delivery mediums and the scope of content.

Topics

Related research

Body Literacy › Patient Education › School and Family Education
Margaret L. Schmitt, Caitlin Gruer, Christine Hagstrom, Nana Ekua Adenu-Mensah, Azure Nowara, Katie Keeley, Marni Sommer
Maggie Schmitt, Peggy Schmitt, M Schmitt, C Gruer, Chris Hagstrom, C Hagstrom, N Adenu-Mensah, A Nowara, Katherine Keeley, K Keeley, M Sommer
DOI 10.3389/frph.2022.1018217 10.3389/frph.2022.1018217 Schmitt et al. 2022, Schmitt 2022