Vitamin A in Pregnancy: The Risks of Too Little and Too Much
Vitamin A in pregnancy has a U-shaped risk. High intakes of preformed vitamin A are linked to birth defects. Too little causes defects in animals and in rare ge...
Breaking Up with IVF Free for membersMidwife and former front-line IVF clinician Dr. Jennifer Mercier joins Dr. Naomi Whittaker for a candid Save the Uterus Club conversation.
Masterclass in Endometriosis & Surgery 9 sectionsComprehensive guide for patients preparing for endometriosis surgery.
Hormones Through the Lifespan Free for membersA comprehensive overview of hormonal health across a woman's life, menstrual cycles, common conditions, and the transition to menopause, presented by Dr. Ana Garcia, OB/GYN.
On October 22, registered dietitian Pam Schoenfeld, MS, RD, LDN, gave the Save the Uterus Club a two-hour talk on one nutrient. Her talk was called "Vitamin A: Critical for Female Fertility." Pam co-wrote the first post in this series with us. Here are the highlights of what she taught.
She opened with three claims. First, vitamin A is needed for a woman's fertility, a man's fertility and a baby's growth. Second, a shortfall often gets missed, because so many people fear vitamin A in pregnancy. That fear is why she named an earlier article "The Scarlet Nutrient." Third, every woman and her partner hoping for a baby should have a source of preformed vitamin A in their nutrition plan. Preformed vitamin A is the ready-made form.
Pam was open about her evidence. Much of it comes from animal studies. Some of the ways she thinks vitamin A works are still ideas that haven't been proven.
The vitamin A in food is mostly retinol, usually bound to a fat. The body changes it, step by step, into retinoic acid. Retinoic acid is the form that matters most for reproduction. It turns about 500 genes on and off, Pam said [29]. The liver stores 80 to 90% of the body's retinol. It sends retinol out on a carrier protein as the tissues need it [30].
Pam called one review a landmark paper on vitamin A and reproduction. (A review is a paper that sums up many other studies.) Its summary reads: "the relative vitamin A status of the female, both at the time of conception and throughout pregnancy, is a critical determinant in reproductive outcome" [1]. The review says a shortfall can stop a pregnancy before the embryo attaches to the womb (implantation). It can also lead to losing the baby or to birth defects [1]. Which one happens depends on how severe the shortfall is.
She also explained why fertility may suffer early. In her words, reproduction is "a luxury function." When the body runs short of a key nutrient, it protects survival first. It lets the less vital jobs slide. Pam called this the triage theory of nutrient allocation [31]. The body sends a scarce nutrient to the jobs that keep it alive first.
The link goes back about a century. Carl Hartman kept opossums in his lab. He fed them skim milk, bread, tallow and lean meat, and they reproduced poorly. In the 1916 to 1917 season, he added organ meats to their food. An eye disease caused by low vitamin A then cleared up [49]. He published the paper in 1924. It doesn't make clear whether their reproduction improved too, or when [49]. Pam, our co-author, reads the paper another way. Hartman linked his work to a finding by Herbert Evans and Katharine Bishop. They had shown that a mild vitamin A shortfall upsets the rat's cycle. So Pam takes the paper to suggest that reproduction improved once he fixed the diet [49]. Both readings are reasonable. The paper doesn't settle it.
Evans and Bishop had found a kind of sterility in rats from a vitamin A shortfall. The shortfall was too mild to harm the rats' general health or weight. It still upset the estrous cycle, the rat's reproductive cycle. Hartman called it a delicate indicator of deficiency, meaning an early and sensitive sign [49]. The sign showed up in the lining of the vagina. Hardened (cornified) cells stayed there instead of changing with the cycle. Some rats were made severely deficient before mating. In them, the hardened cells stay in the vaginal smear, a sample of cells from the vagina. Reproduction fails before the embryo can implant [1].
Cod liver oil turned the smear back to normal, Pam said. Sometimes this took 24 hours, and it always took three days or less [11]. Two human papers found that vitamin A improved the same kind of vaginal changes in women after menopause. In a 1936 paper, 30 women with vaginal inflammation after menopause took cod liver oil or halibut liver oil. By two months, most had no symptoms, and their smears showed fewer hardened cells [50]. A 1951 report on five women found that vitamin A changed the same smear picture [51].
One detail stood out to Pam. The rats' cycles turned irregular and long only when the shortfall was advanced [32]. Before that, an animal could keep cycling on schedule and still fail to reproduce. Pam sees a parallel in some women. Their cycles are regular, yet they have struggled to conceive for years. She raised it as a research question: could fertility trouble be the earliest sign of low vitamin A?
The standard blood test won't catch an early or mild shortfall. It measures retinol in the blood (serum retinol). The body keeps that level steady until the liver's stores are nearly gone [2]. That's why Pam rarely asks for the test. She looks for signs in the body instead. These tend to show up after a longer shortfall:
Each sign can have other causes, Pam said, such as low omega-3 fats or low zinc. Zinc helps carry vitamin A to the tissues and switch it on. It takes six months to two years to use up the body's stores fully. The time depends on how much a person had to start [52, 59].
Pam said that in animal research, vitamin A is needed at every stage of reproduction. These stages start with the growth of the follicle (the small sac that holds an egg), the ripening of the egg and the work of the fallopian tube. They go on to embryo quality, implantation, making progesterone and the growth of the baby's cells [1, 12]. Proteins that carry retinol turn up in the ovaries, the fluid around the egg and the tubes [33, 34, 35]. They also turn up in the lining of the uterus and in the corpus luteum, the gland that forms after ovulation and makes progesterone [33, 34, 35]. Female rats kept mildly deficient still conceive. But their embryos often die midway through pregnancy [1].
Pam then went through the areas where she thinks low vitamin A can cause infertility or add to it. That includes "unexplained" infertility. She said it can often be explained.
Ovulation. Retinoids are vitamin A and the compounds the body makes from it. Their signals help control how the ovary develops and the hormones it makes. They also help control how the egg ripens and how the corpus luteum forms [12, 13]. In deficient mice, more follicles died off. The cycle also stalled in a way that pointed to a problem with the LH surge, the hormone spike that sets off ovulation [12]. In one small human study, women who weren't ovulating had lower blood retinol than women who were. Their levels still weren't low enough to count as deficient [14].
PCOS, now renamed PMOS (Polyendocrine Metabolic Ovarian Syndrome). Some women with irregular cycles show no signs of high androgens, hormones such as testosterone. In those women, Pam questions the PCOS label before she accepts it. Many things can stop ovulation, and running short of nutrients is one of them. One paper she found suggested that retinoid signals don't work normally in PCOS [13].
Oxidative stress and seed oils. Oxidative stress is damage to cells, including the fats in their outer layer. Vitamin A helps cells resist it. Pam pointed to Western diets heavy in industrial seed oils, which are high in omega-6 fats. She cited data that linked eating more polyunsaturated fat to earlier natural menopause. Total fat and saturated fat showed no link [15]. Sperm are very sensitive to this kind of damage too. Fried food is the one food Pam asks both partners to drop. "Fried foods have got to go," she said.
Egg supply. Before a baby girl is born, retinoic acid signals the start of egg growth in her ovaries. Pam said it may shape how many eggs she ends up with [16]. Her point was about the next generation. A mother's vitamin A may matter for her daughter's fertility.
Fallopian tubes. The lining of the tube has cells with tiny hairs called cilia. It also has secretory (goblet) cells that make fluid. The lining of the airway is much the same. Moving an egg, sperm and embryo depends on three things: the tube's muscle squeezing, the cilia beating and the flow of tube fluid [3]. Pam's theory is that the secretory cells need vitamin A to make that fluid. Without it, the cilia may become abnormal, as they can in the lungs. An ectopic pregnancy is one that implants outside the uterus. Tubes from ectopic pregnancies show fewer cells with cilia [17]. And up to half of women with an ectopic pregnancy have no risk factor that can be found [53]. Part 6 of this series covers what research has and hasn't found on vitamin A and tubal cilia.
Progesterone and thyroid. Pam said vitamin A helps the body make progesterone. One study looked at 52 Holstein cows. In winter, when the cows' blood beta-carotene was low, cells from their corpus luteum made less progesterone in the lab. Blood vitamin A showed no such link [54]. Pam notes that the animal evidence points more to beta-carotene than to retinol. She also notes that these animals eat only plants. In people, an older study gave vitamin A to 50 pregnant women who were undernourished and low in vitamin A. They were 16 to 20 weeks pregnant. Their blood progesterone rose more than in women who didn't get vitamin A. Their estrogen didn't change [55, 56]. Vitamin A and thyroid hormone also work together at the thyroid hormone receptor, the part of a cell that responds to thyroid hormone. And the body needs thyroid hormone to turn beta-carotene into vitamin A [36]. One study looked at women who weren't trying to conceive. In them, vitamin A supplements lowered TSH, the signal that tells the thyroid to work harder. They also raised T3, an active thyroid hormone [18].
Gut, immunity and sleep. Along with vitamin D, vitamin A helps keep the seals between the cells of the gut lining (tight junctions) intact [19]. It helps the immune system accept what it should and fight what it should [20, 21]. The body also needs it to clear out foreign chemicals [22, 23]. And it's concentrated in the pineal gland, a small gland in the brain that makes melatonin, the sleep hormone [43].
Implantation and the placenta. In animals, too little vitamin A can leave patches of hard, scaly cells in the lining of the uterus. These patches can make it harder for an embryo to implant [37, 38]. The early embryo needs vitamin A to time when its genes switch on and off. The heart is one of the first organs to form. Pam said vitamin A also helps build and maintain the placenta [1].
Endometriosis. Pam said vitamin A may help lower the extra estrogen seen in endometriosis [44, 45]. One review lays out how this might work inside the tissue. Progesterone helps cells of the uterine lining make retinoic acid. Retinoic acid then signals nearby cells to turn estradiol, a strong form of estrogen, into a weaker one. Endometriosis cells resist progesterone and make too little retinoic acid, so estradiol builds up [4]. A paper Pam cited proposed retinoid supplements as a possible long-term way to manage endometriosis [24]. She kept it in proportion. Vitamin A won't fix everything, she said. But correcting a deficiency could help.
Pam reviewed several IVF studies that measured vitamins in follicular fluid, the fluid around a developing egg. These are research findings:
Her takeaway was about timing. Build up nutrient levels well before trying to conceive. She also warned against piling on antioxidants. Too much vitamin C can cause problems. So can vitamin E taken only as alpha-tocopherol, one form of it.
Diet comes first. Few women eat liver, many eat few egg yolks, and full-fat dairy has fallen out of favor. Our first post in this series traced those changes.
Pam showed federal data on women of childbearing age. Almost half got less vitamin A than the average requirement, even counting beta-carotene from plants [46]. In a national survey of 1,003 pregnant women, 15.5% fell short even with supplements counted [5]. Vitamin A still isn't named a nutrient of public health concern. Pam thinks it should be.
She also questioned diet advice built mostly on plants. Mediterranean-style diets don't focus on foods rich in vitamin A, she said. She pointed to the Nurses' Health Study II, a large study that followed a big group of women over time. In that study, some women ate low-fat dairy two or more times a day. They had a higher risk of infertility from ovulation problems than women who ate it once a week or less. Full-fat dairy leaned the other way [6]. The study didn't explain why. Pam suspects vitamin A is one reason, along with other parts of milk fat.
Genes rank high on her list. Plant foods supply beta-carotene, which the body has to turn into vitamin A. Common versions (variants) of the BCO1 gene slow that step. In one UK study of women, two common variants showed up in 42% and 24% of gene copies. Women who carried both turned about 69% less beta-carotene into vitamin A [7]. Part 3 of this series covers this step in detail. Pam carries such variants herself. For years she ate a mostly plant-based diet and had irregular cycles. They became regular after she changed how she ate.
Pam separates risk factors from true drains. Risk factors make a shortfall more likely. They include gene variants and low zinc and iron, since both minerals help move vitamin A out of storage. They also include obesity, fatty liver disease, diabetes, low thyroid, gut problems and weight-loss (bariatric) surgery. A fatty liver stores vitamin A poorly, she explained. Other things actively use vitamin A up. These are alcohol, smoking and other air pollution, and past pregnancies and breastfeeding. Frequent infections and long-term (chronic) inflammation use it up too.
Of all of these, Pam thinks past pregnancies and long stretches of breastfeeding may be the biggest risk, though they aren't the most common one. She suspects this can be one cause of secondary infertility. That means trouble conceiving after having an earlier child. In her practice, she has seen what she believes was secondary infertility resolve once a woman added a prenatal containing retinol. This is her clinical experience. No study has tested it.
Pam calls vitamin A a Goldilocks nutrient. Too little and too much both carry risk.
She traced today's fear to three sources. The first is isotretinoin (Accutane), an acne drug. It's a form of retinoic acid. The second is animal studies that used very high doses. The third is a 1995 study. It linked high intakes of preformed vitamin A in early pregnancy to birth defects [8]. In Pam's view, later studies haven't backed up that finding [39, 40]. Part 4 of this series lays out the evidence on both sides.
Liver is where most people worry. In Pam's view, it's the only food that can push intake too high. And in her view, no one has shown that eating liver once a week causes birth defects. In 1990, an editorial in the BMJ, a British medical journal, found only one reported case of birth defects in a child whose mother ate large amounts of liver every day [57]. Its author wrote that telling women to avoid liver completely might read too much into very limited evidence [57]. A 2000 review listed a 1997 study of more than 900 babies with birth defects. In that study, eating liver didn't raise the risk [39, 58]. Traditional diets often included a serving of liver a week, she said. She also cited a Canadian public health journal that called small servings of liver in pregnancy a sensible choice [41]. When a woman eats liver, Pam still keeps her on her prenatal, mainly for the folate.
The amount of vitamin A in cod liver oil varies, and some bottles don't list it. Pam picks products that state their vitamin A, so she knows the amount. She also thinks it's safer when someone looks at the whole diet. A dietitian who checks what a woman eats knows where her vitamin A is coming from.
Many prenatals use only beta-carotene, and some have no vitamin A at all. In a count of 214 US prenatal vitamins, about a quarter listed none [9]. In a review of 188, 35% had preformed vitamin A and 73% had beta-carotene [10]. Part 2 of this series covers how to read the label.
Pam prefers prenatal vitamins that include retinol, often along with some beta-carotene. She steers women away from gummies unless they can't swallow pills. She also watches the balance with vitamin D. Many prenatals carry a lot of it. She says high vitamin D needs enough vitamin A alongside it. She has urged a federal health official to set standards for what a prenatal must contain.
Timing matters to her too. Many women start a prenatal only once they know they're pregnant. But the heart begins forming in the first weeks, and it needs vitamin A from the start.
Pam starts with the signs above and a review of the diet and supplements. She never looks at vitamin A by itself. She looks at the whole picture. That includes iron and ferritin (the body's iron stores), zinc and copper, and B12. Here is her general plan, which she summed up "in a nutshell":
Pam treats every woman she sees as though she could already be pregnant. So she keeps supplement amounts modest.
She works with both partners. For couples, she suggests two or three months of focused nutrition first. That sets a new baseline, a fresh starting point. Testing after that gives a truer picture.
Diet quality comes before weight loss in her approach. Pam doesn't suggest GLP-1 weight-loss drugs to a woman hoping to conceive soon. They can't be used in pregnancy. The weight can come back when a woman stops them. And some women eat too little on them.
She also wants vitamin A to be part of every fertility workup. "It should be a required part of the assessment," she said.
In the discussion, Dr. Whittaker said Pam's list of signs of low vitamin A matched patterns she saw in clinical practice. She named progesterone deficiency and ovulation defects. She named luteinized unruptured follicle syndrome, when a follicle matures but doesn't release its egg. She also named iron deficiency and subclinical hypothyroidism, a mildly underactive thyroid. She pointed to animal studies in which grass-fed cows had a richer-colored corpus luteum [47, 48]. Vitamin A seems to do two things at once, she said. It lowers the less healthy estrogen in the pelvis, and it supports progesterone. That made her wonder about repeated miscarriage (recurrent pregnancy loss) as well, through progesterone and immune balance.
She raised a harder question too. Even with a restorative approach, she said, some of the treatments in use could hide a nutrient deficiency.
Her last question was about tubes. When patients asked why their tubes were blocked, she often had no answer. Smoking is linked to ectopic pregnancy [42], and it affects how tubal cilia work [3]. She wondered whether infections that damage the tubes might also lower vitamin A there. It's an open question.
Members can watch the full replay in the Save the Uterus Club library. Pam's slides carry her full list of references. Join the Save the Uterus Club, RRM Academy's community, for the full session library. If you're planning a pregnancy, watch it together. Vitamin A is a question for both of you.
This is part 5 of our series on vitamin A:
Dr. Naomi Whittaker is a board-certified OBGYN. Pam Schoenfeld is a registered dietitian who has written about vitamin A for a decade. This article is educational and is not medical advice or a substitute for care from your own clinician.