General Gynecology · Pelvic Pain

Machine Learning Revealed New Correlates of Chronic Pelvic Pain in Women

Elgendi M, Allaire C, Williams C, Bedaiwy MA, Yong PJ

Published December 18, 2020 Frontiers in digital health
DOI 10.3389/fdgth.2020.600604 PMID 34713065 PMC PMC8521902

RRM Academy Synopsis

Chronic pelvic pain correlates with depression and anxiety scores

Chronic pelvic pain scores moved together with depression, anxiety and Pain Catastrophizing Scale scores in a machine learning analysis of 656 women at a pelvic pain and endometriosis center. Three unsupervised methods agreed on that grouping. They also linked body mass index with smoking and life trauma, and deep dyspareunia with musculoskeletal pain.

Key Findings

  • The analysis re-used cross-sectional data from 656 women seen at one tertiary center that specializes in pelvic pain and endometriosis, with 25 clinical factors recorded for each woman.
  • The three methods agreed on a correlation between chronic pelvic pain, the Endometriosis Health Profile, anxiety score, depression score and the Pain Catastrophizing Scale.
  • Hierarchical cluster analysis grouped body mass index with trauma and smoking, and deep dyspareunia with abdominal wall pain and pelvic floor tenderness. The authors did not see this musculoskeletal relationship for dysmenorrhea.
  • Younger age at first pain went with longer pain duration and a higher likelihood of confirmed endometriosis. Endometriosis itself was not associated with chronic pelvic pain, matching the earlier regression analysis.

Interpretation

The study is a cross-sectional re-analysis of one referral-center database, so the findings describe correlations and clusters. None shows that one factor causes another. The three methods are unsupervised: they group factors by similarity without a defined outcome. The authors read the dendrogram by visual inspection. They describe the body mass index, trauma and smoking link as a hypothesis for further study. Of the women, 57% had endometriosis and 74% were Caucasian. The authors add that chronic pelvic pain is heterogeneous and that larger multi-center samples are needed.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine looks for the root cause of pain in each woman. The paper reports correlations that sit beside endometriosis: chronic pelvic pain with mood and pain-coping scores, and deep dyspareunia with abdominal wall and pelvic floor pain. The authors note that several underlying diagnoses can be present in chronic pelvic pain. That observation supports a full evaluation before any single explanation is accepted.

Abstract

Chronic pelvic pain affects one in seven women worldwide, and there is an urgent need to reduce its associated significant costs and to improve women's health. There are many correlated factors associated with chronic pelvic pain (CPP), and analyzing them simultaneously can be complex and involves many challenges. A newly developed interaction ensemble, referred to as INTENSE, was implemented to investigate this research gap. When applied, INTENSE aggregates three machine learning (ML) methods, which are unsupervised, as follows: interaction principal component analysis (IPCA), hierarchical cluster analysis (HCA), and centroid-based clustering (CBC). For our proposed research, we used INTENSE to uncover novel knowledge, which revealed new interactions in a sample of 656 patients among 25 factors: age, parity, ethnicity, body mass index, endometriosis, irritable bowel syndrome, painful bladder syndrome, pelvic floor tenderness, abdominal wall pain, depression score, anxiety score, Pain Catastrophizing Scale, family history of chronic pain, new or re-referral, age when first experienced pain, pain duration, surgery helpful for pain, infertility, smoking, alcohol use, trauma, dysmenorrhea, deep dyspareunia, CPP, and the Endometriosis Health Profile for functional quality of life. INTENSE indicates that CPP and the Endometriosis Health Profile are correlated with depression score, anxiety score, and the Pain Catastrophizing Scale. Other insights derived from these ML methods include the finding that higher body mass index was clustered with smoking and a history of life trauma. As well, sexual pain (deep dyspareunia) was found to be associated with musculoskeletal pain contributors (abdominal wall pain and pelvic floor tenderness). Therefore, INTENSE provided expert-like reasoning without training any model or prior knowledge of CPP. ML has the potential to identify novel relationships in the etiology of CPP, and thus can drive innovative future research.

Topics

By this author

Related research

General Gynecology › Pelvic Pain › Chronic Pelvic Pain · Research Methods › Measurement and Statistics › Statistical Methods
Mohamed Elgendi, Catherine Allaire, Christina Williams, Mohamed A Bedaiwy, Paul J Yong
M Elgendi, Cathy Allaire, Kate Allaire, C Allaire, C Williams, M Bedaiwy, P Yong
PMID 34713065 34713065 DOI 10.3389/fdgth.2020.600604 10.3389/fdgth.2020.600604 Elgendi et al. 2020, Elgendi 2020