Diagnostics Endometrial Assessment

Microbiological and Cytokine Profiling of Menstrual Blood for the Assessment of Endometrial Receptivity: A Pilot Study

Jain M, Mladova E, Shichanina A, Kirillova K, Povarova A, Scherbakova L, Samokhodskaya L, Panina O

Published April 26, 2023 Biomedicines, 11(5)
DOI 10.3390/biomedicines11051284 PMID 37238954 PMC PMC10215904

RRM Academy Synopsis

Menstrual blood immune markers differed by embryo transfer outcome

In a pilot cohort of 42 patients scheduled for frozen embryo transfer, patients who got pregnant had different levels of 12 immune markers in menstrual blood. Microbial profiles did not differ with the outcome. In this cohort, IP-10 and SCGF-β were also lower in patients with endometriosis, with IP-10 of borderline significance.

Key Findings

  • The study included 42 patients scheduled for frozen embryo transfer (cryo-ET). Nineteen became pregnant and 23 did not.
  • Twelve cytokines differed between the groups (p < 0.05). Five of them (M-CSF, TRAIL, SCF, IP-10 and MIG) remained significant after adjustment for multiple comparisons.
  • In this cohort, IP-10 and MIG had areas under the ROC curve of 0.762 and 0.773, respectively, for the pregnancy outcome. The authors say validation in a larger cohort is needed.
  • Neither abundances nor detection rates of the 28 microbial taxa differed by pregnancy outcome (p > 0.05).
  • Patients with endometriosis had lower levels of IP-10 (p = 0.044) and SCGF-β (p = 0.015, which passed the multiple-comparison threshold) than patients without the condition. The authors call IP-10 borderline.

Interpretation

The authors call this a pilot study, an exploratory first study of a new sampling method. Researchers aspirated menstrual blood from the uterine cavity early in the cryo-ET cycle. With groups this small, the authors could not build an unbiased prognostic model. Pregnancy meant clinical pregnancy, and live birth was not evaluated. The authors note that early-cycle cytokine levels may differ from levels on the day of transfer, and that their adjustment for multiple comparisons was not strict. They present the markers as candidates for larger future studies.

RRM Context

The study asks how well markers predict an embryo transfer result. IVF bypasses the reproductive system and leaves the cause of infertility unresolved. Lower IP-10 and SCGF-β in endometriosis adds to evidence that the lining of the uterus differs in that disease. Restorative reproductive medicine looks for such causes directly. Excision surgery treats endometriosis, a diagnosable cause of infertility.

Abstract

Endometrial receptivity (ER) is a key factor required for the successful implantation of the embryo. However, the evaluation of ER is challenging, as a nondisruptive sampling of endometrial biomaterial by conventional methods is only possible outside of the embryo transfer (ET) cycle. We propose a novel approach for the assessment of ER-microbiological and cytokine profiling of menstrual blood aspirated directly from the uterine cavity at the beginning of the cryo-ET cycle. The aim of the pilot study was to evaluate its prognostic potential regarding the outcome of the in vitro fertilization procedure. Samples collected from a cohort of 42 patients undergoing cryo-ET were analyzed by a multiplex immunoassay (48 various cytokines, chemokines, and growth factors) and a real-time PCR assay (28 relevant microbial taxa and 3 members of the Herpesviridae family). Significant differences between groups of patients who achieved and did not achieve pregnancy were observed for G-CSF, GRO-α, IL-6, IL-9, MCP-1, M-CSF, SDF-1α, TNF-β, TRAIL, SCF, IP-10, and MIG (p < 0.05), whereas microbial profiles were not associated with the outcome of cryo-ET. It appeared that levels of IP-10 and SCGF-β were significantly lower (p < 0.05), in patients with endometriosis. Menstrual blood may provide great opportunities to noninvasively investigate various parameters of the endometrium.

Topics

Related research

Diagnostics › Endometrial Assessment › Receptivity Testing · Genetics and Immunology › Reproductive Immunology › Implantation Immunology · Assisted Reproduction › Add-Ons and Adjuncts › Adjunct Evidence Base
Mark Jain, Elena Mladova, Anna Shichanina, Karina Kirillova, Anna Povarova, Liya Scherbakova, Larisa Samokhodskaya, Olga Panina
M Jain, E Mladova, A Shichanina, K Kirillova, A Povarova, L Scherbakova, L Samokhodskaya, O Panina
PMID 37238954 37238954 DOI 10.3390/biomedicines11051284 10.3390/biomedicines11051284 Jain et al. 2023, Jain 2023