Perinatal and maternal outcomes by planned place of birth for healthy women with low risk pregnancies: the Birthplace in England national prospective cohort study

Brocklehurst P, Hardy P, Hollowell J, Linsell L, Macfarlane A, McCourt C, Marlow N, Miller A, Newburn M, Petrou S, Puddicombe D, Redshaw M, Rowe R, Sandall J, Silverton L, Stewart M

Published November 23, 2011 BMJ (Clinical research ed.)
DOI 10.1136/bmj.d7400 PMID 22117057 PMC PMC3223531

RRM Academy Synopsis

Overall, low risk births had similar serious baby outcomes by planned place

Overall, 64,538 healthy women with low risk pregnancies in England had no significant difference in serious baby outcomes by planned birth setting. In this cohort study, planning a home birth was associated with higher odds of a serious outcome for first-time mothers. Planned births outside hospital obstetric units involved fewer interventions.

Key Findings

  • Planned home birth carried higher odds of the primary outcome for nulliparous women (first-time mothers), with an adjusted odds ratio of 1.75 (95% CI 1.07 to 2.86).
  • Nulliparous women had 9.3 events per 1000 births (95% CI 6.5 to 13.1) with planned home birth and 5.3 (3.9 to 7.3) in obstetric units.
  • Combining every woman, the 250 events gave 4.3 per 1000 births (95% CI 3.3 to 5.5), with no significant gap between obstetric units and any other setting.
  • Multiparous women, who had given birth before, showed no significant differences in the primary outcome (serious baby outcomes) by planned place of birth.
  • A "normal birth" occurred for 58% of planned obstetric unit births, 76% alongside midwifery units, 83% freestanding midwifery units, and 88% planned home births.

Interpretation

The Birthplace study is a prospective cohort. Women were grouped by where they planned to give birth when labor care began, whatever happened next. Women planning home birth were older and lived in more advantaged areas, and the analysis adjusted for several maternal factors. Most individual outcomes were rare, so the authors combined them into one measure. Among women planning birth outside an obstetric unit, many moved to a hospital obstetric unit: 36% to 45% of first-time mothers, against 9% to 13% of women with earlier births. The authors note that results may not apply where care is organized differently from England's midwife-led NHS system.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine treats pregnancy and birth as body processes to support. The Birthplace data give that principle outcome evidence. In a healthy, low risk group, planning birth outside an obstetric unit came with substantially lower rates of intervention. Women who had given birth before showed no significant difference in serious outcomes in any setting.

Abstract

Objective

To compare perinatal outcomes, maternal outcomes, and interventions in labour by planned place of birth at the start of care in labour for women with low risk pregnancies.

Design

Prospective cohort study.

Setting

England: all NHS trusts providing intrapartum care at home, all freestanding midwifery units, all alongside midwifery units (midwife led units on a hospital site with an obstetric unit), and a stratified random sample of obstetric units.

Participants

64,538 eligible women with a singleton, term (≥37 weeks gestation), and "booked" pregnancy who gave birth between April 2008 and April 2010. Planned caesarean sections and caesarean sections before the onset of labour and unplanned home births were excluded.

Main Outcome Measures

A composite primary outcome of perinatal mortality and intrapartum related neonatal morbidities (stillbirth after start of care in labour, early neonatal death, neonatal encephalopathy, meconium aspiration syndrome, brachial plexus injury, fractured humerus, or fractured clavicle) was used to compare outcomes by planned place of birth at the start of care in labour (at home, freestanding midwifery units, alongside midwifery units, and obstetric units).

Results

There were 250 primary outcome events and an overall weighted incidence of 4.3 per 1000 births (95% CI 3.3 to 5.5). Overall, there were no significant differences in the adjusted odds of the primary outcome for any of the non-obstetric unit settings compared with obstetric units. For nulliparous women, the odds of the primary outcome were higher for planned home births (adjusted odds ratio 1.75, 95% CI 1.07 to 2.86) but not for either midwifery unit setting. For multiparous women, there were no significant differences in the incidence of the primary outcome by planned place of birth. Interventions during labour were substantially lower in all non-obstetric unit settings. Transfers from non-obstetric unit settings were more frequent for nulliparous women (36% to 45%) than for multiparous women (9% to 13%).

Conclusions

The results support a policy of offering healthy women with low risk pregnancies a choice of birth setting. Women planning birth in a midwifery unit and multiparous women planning birth at home experience fewer interventions than those planning birth in an obstetric unit with no impact on perinatal outcomes. For nulliparous women, planned home births also have fewer interventions but have poorer perinatal outcomes.

By this author

Related research

Peter Brocklehurst, Pollyanna Hardy, Jennifer Hollowell, Louise Linsell, Alison Macfarlane, Christine McCourt, Neil Marlow, Alison Miller, Mary Newburn, Stavros Petrou, David Puddicombe, Maggie Redshaw, Rachel Rowe, Jane Sandall, Louise Silverton, Mary Stewart
Pete Brocklehurst, P Brocklehurst, P Hardy, Jen Hollowell, Jenny Hollowell, J Hollowell, L Linsell, A Macfarlane, Chris McCourt, C McCourt, N Marlow, A Miller, M Newburn, S Petrou, Dave Puddicombe, D Puddicombe, Margaret Redshaw, M Redshaw, R Rowe, J Sandall, L Silverton, M Stewart
PMID 22117057 22117057 DOI 10.1136/bmj.d7400 10.1136/bmj.d7400 Brocklehurst P; Hardy P; Hollowell J; Linsell L; Macfarlane A; McCourt C; Marlow N; Miller A; Newburn M; Petrou S; Puddicombe D; Redshaw M; Rowe R; Sandall J; Silverton L; Stewart et al. 2011, Brocklehurst P; Hardy P; Hollowell J; Linsell L; Macfarlane A; McCourt C; Marlow N; Miller A; Newburn M; Petrou S; Puddicombe D; Redshaw M; Rowe R; Sandall J; Silverton L; Stewart 2011