Mental Health and Psychosocial Care Grief and Loss

Providing hospice in the womb

Collier R

Published March 22, 2011 CMAJ : Canadian Medical Association Journal = Journal De l'Association Medicale Canadienne, 183(5), E267-E268
DOI 10.1503/cmaj.109-3776 PMID 21343271 PMC PMC3060208

RRM Academy Synopsis

Perinatal hospice gives families a care plan for a baby's brief life

A 2011 CMAJ news feature reports that perinatal hospice starts at prenatal diagnosis and supports families before, during and after pregnancy. The article quotes a parent advocate, two physicians and a nurse. Programs on the advocate's list grew from 10 in 2006 to 90 in 2011.

Key Findings

  • Perinatal hospice starts when a prenatal diagnosis is made, with birth planning and early medical decisions, and aims to keep a baby comfortable during a short life.
  • The advocate Amy Kuebelbeck lists hospitals with perinatal hospice programs, mostly in the United States and Canada. The list held 10 programs in 2006 and 90 in 2011.
  • For their book A Gift of Time, Kuebelbeck and psychologist Deborah Davis interviewed 120 families in North America, Europe and Australia who had lost a baby to a life-limiting illness.
  • Some of those families described supportive medical caretakers. Others felt abandoned or were made to feel that continuing the pregnancy was a mistake.
  • Planning can cover a baby who lives longer than expected, shorter than expected, dies in utero or needs resuscitation, so parents decide ahead of the moment.

Interpretation

The source is a journalist's news feature, tenth in a CMAJ series on end-of-life care. Its claims rest on interviews with named people. The count of 90 programs comes from a list that one advocate maintains. One obstetrician expects that many families would choose perinatal hospice over termination if it were offered. He cites a 2001 paper he coauthored.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine centers on the couple and on the whole course of reproductive life, including loss. Perinatal hospice shares that outlook after a prenatal diagnosis changes what a pregnancy is expected to bring. Care continues for the family through birth and afterward. A quoted nurse reports that families want time to hold their babies and sing to them.

Abstract not indexed.

Topics

Related research

Mental Health and Psychosocial Care › Grief and Loss › Stillbirth and Infant Loss · Ethics and Policy › Reproductive Ethics › Embryo Status
Roger Collier
R Collier
PMID 21343271 21343271 DOI 10.1503/cmaj.109-3776 10.1503/cmaj.109-3776 Collier et al. 2011, Collier 2011