Diagnostics Endometrial Assessment

The effect of interobserver variation in dating endometrial histology on the diagnosis of luteal phase defects

Scott RT, Snyder RR, Strickland DM, Tyburski CC, Bagnall JA, Reed KR, Adair CA, Hensley SB

Published December 1988 Fertility and Sterility, 50(6), 888-892
DOI 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)60367-9 PMID 3203751

RRM Academy Synopsis

A second pathologist would change about 2 in 10 biopsy calls

In a 1988 US Air Force Medical Center study of endometrial biopsies, a second pathologist would change the in-phase or out-of-phase reading in about 2 in 10 cases. Five pathologists dated 62 specimens. Mean interobserver variation was 0.96 days. The authors conclude that luteal phase defect needs a more precise diagnosis.

Key Findings

  • Five pathologists dated 62 biopsy specimens. Mean interobserver variation was 0.96 ± 0.08 days, compared with 1.46 ± 0.07 days reported by Noyes and Haman (P<0.01).
  • Variation did not differ between mid and late luteal phase biopsies, by the lag before the next menses, or by the presence of a luteal phase defect (LPD).
  • A second pathologist reading the same specimen would reverse the in-phase or out-of-phase call in 22% of cases.
  • Altered patient management had a probability of 22% to 39%. The figure was 39% when the first biopsy read as out of phase, and 22% when it read as in phase.
  • One-day and 2-day dating ranges gave similar variation: 0.96 ± 0.08 days and 0.93 ± 0.08 days.

Interpretation

This retrospective review used archived biopsy specimens, 31 lagging by 2 or more days and 31 without. Five pathologists dated them with no clinical information. The authors chose general pathologists, who read biopsies for practicing clinicians, and only one was a gynecopathologist. A diagnosis of luteal phase defect (LPD) needs two out-of-phase biopsies in a row, so the authors calculated how often redating would alter it. The management figures are those calculated probabilities. The authors state they do not question that LPD exists as a clinical entity.

RRM Context

RRM reads luteal function across the whole cycle. The authors cite a review saying temperature charts, hormone blood tests, ultrasound and urine LH tests may be useful for diagnosing luteal disorders.

Abstract

Endometrial biopsy specimens (n = 62) were evaluated by five pathologists to assess the effect of interobserver variation on histologic dating of the endometrium. The potential effect of this variation on the diagnosis of luteal phase defects (LPDs) and resulting clinical management was also determined. Mean (+/- standard error) interobserver variation was 0.96 +/- 0.08 days, comparable to results reported by other investigators. The magnitude of the variation was not affected by whether the biopsy specimen was obtained in the mid or late luteal phase, the degree of lag between the dating and subsequent menses, or the presence of an LPD. Redating of a specimen by another pathologist would have resulted in a change in the determination of "in" or "out" of phase in 22% of cases. The subsequent probability of changing patient management altered ranged from 22% to 39% depending on the clinical setting.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Diagnostics › Endometrial Assessment › Luteal Phase Biopsy · Research Methods › Measurement and Statistics › Research Tooling and Reproducibility · Menstrual Cycle › Cycle Disorders › Ovulatory Disturbances
Richard T. Scott, Russell R. Snyder, Daniel M. Strickland, Claudia C. Tyburski, James A. Bagnall, Kurt R. Reed, Carol A. Adair, Samuel B. Hensley
Rick Scott, Dick Scott, Rich Scott, R Scott, R Snyder, Dan Strickland, Danny Strickland, D Strickland, C Tyburski, Jim Bagnall, Jimmy Bagnall, J Bagnall, K Reed, C Adair, Sam Hensley, S Hensley
PMID 3203751 3203751 DOI 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)60367-9 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)60367-9 Scott et al. 1988, Scott 1988