Zufferey, M. M. (1986). The risks of the natural family planning methods. Therapeutische Umschau. Revue Therapeutique, 43(5), 417-424.
Zufferey MM. The risks of the natural family planning methods. Ther Umsch. 1986;43(5):417-424.
Zufferey, M. M. "The risks of the natural family planning methods." Therapeutische Umschau. Revue Therapeutique, vol. 43, no. 5, 1986, pp. 417-424.
For EndNote, Zotero or Mendeley:
License
Open-access status not yet checked.
RRM Academy Synopsis
Natural family planning carries a risk of pregnancy, a review argues
Critical to restorative reproductive medicine
A 1986 review examined five natural family planning methods. It found that pregnancy from method failure or user error is the main risk of these methods. The methods covered are calendar, temperature, Bioself thermometer, mucus, and symptothermal.
Key Findings
The author says the symptothermal method has high effectiveness rates, with pregnancy risks generally the same as those of the mucus and temperature methods.
The author reports that some authors found flat, one-phase temperature curves in 3-20% of cycles in which ovulation occurred.
The author says the Bioself thermometer, which stores the 6 most recent cycle lengths for cycles of 19-39 days, has no formal evaluation in the literature.
The author says the calendar method, based on the past 6-12 cycles, was seldom taught at the time of writing because it fails often.
The author names four routes to pregnancy: method failure, poor instruction, user error, and failure to abstain through the whole fertile period.
Interpretation
This narrative review surveys published work on natural family planning methods. The author says a higher risk of miscarriage or birth defects from aging eggs or sperm has not been proven. The authors note that it is hard to compare how well the methods work. The findings support larger studies of how these methods are taught and used.
RRM Context
Restorative reproductive medicine uses cycle charting to find root causes, and it evaluates before it treats. This review examines how natural family planning methods are taught and read. A woman who can read her cycle well shares that same goal.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract
Risks of 5 natural family planning (NFP) methods are compared. The main risk of these methods is the risk of pregnancy stemming from method failure, errors in instruction, error in application of the method, and failure to observe abstinence during the entire fertile period. The calendar rhythm method, the oldest NFP method, is based on calculation of likely fertile days in the preceding 6-12 menstrual cycles. The method is seldom taught at present because of its high failure rate, but it continues to be used, often by individuals with an incomplete understanding of the calculations. The principle of the basal body temperature method is well known. The thermal shift affirms the beginning of the infertile period but does not allow prediction of ovulation. Instructions provided by different organizations to identify the third day of the hyperthermal plateau are not standardized; the various interpretations applied to the same cycle do not necessarily lead to identification of the same day as the start of the infertile period. Comparisons of efficacy between methods are therefore difficult. Well-conducted prospective studies have demonstrated high theoretical efficacy, but failure rates in practice appear to be higher. Women often do not know how to interpret a temperature curve correctly, and the curve may be influenced by illness, sleeping late, a change of life style or thermometer. Some authors have reported that 3-20% of ovulatory cycles have monophasic temperature curves. The temperature method requires lengthy abstinence lasting until the third day of higher temperature, which may create conflicts in some couples. To ease the difficulties of interpretation of the temperature method, a Swiss architect developed an electronic thermometer programmed according to rules of the calendar rhythm method for cycles of 19-39 days. The woman's 6 most recent cycle lengths remain in the memory to indicate probable infertile days. Although no formal evaluations have appeared in the literature on the Bioself thermometer, the method appears to entail risks including registration of incorrect temperature due to humidity or rundown batteries, and inadequate programming to identify the safe period. The Billings or cervical mucus method is based on observation by the woman of the thickness, wetness, and other characteristics of mucus secretions in the vulva to predict ovulation. Various studies have shown high theoretical efficacy but practical efficacy is lower. Vaginal infections, some ovarian pathologies, and postpartum hormonal changes are among factors that can alter mucus patterns. The method does not confirm ovulation, and false "peak days" may occur. The symptothermal method is based on all the principles of the cervical mucus and temperature methods as well as autopalpation of the cervix and any other signs of ovulation. Effectiveness rates are high. In general pregnancy risks are the same as those for the cervical mucus and temperature methods. A theoretical heightened risk of abortion or fetal malformation common to all the methods due to fertilization of aging gametes has not been definitively evaluated. Another possible risk results from timing of abstinence at the phase of the menstrual cycle when the woman's sexual desire is likely to be greatest.
Clinician-reviewed comparison of fertility awareness-based methods (Billings, Creighton, Sensiplan, Marquette, Standard Days, apps). Every effectiveness figure cited and labeled by metric.