A personal professional journey: the real history of restorative and responsible reproductive medicine

Rebar RW

Published December 2025 Fertility and sterility, 124(6), 1189-1190
DOI 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2025.09.015 PMID 41352767

RRM Academy Synopsis

Rebar essay cites no data but calls restorative medicine outmoded

Hostile to restorative reproductive medicine

Rebar's 2025 essay calls restorative reproductive medicine (RRM) an outdated way to treat infertility. He is an IVF doctor (a reproductive endocrinologist) who trained in the 1970s. The essay reports no data. His five references include no study of RRM care or its results.

Key Findings

  • The essay's five references are Rebar's own Merck Manual chapter, a 1999 sperm-extraction paper, two ASRM Practice Committee documents and a WHO guideline listed as submitted.
  • Rebar argues that proponents center care on the woman and may delay pregnancy needlessly.
  • The closing paragraph, which carries no citation, describes proponents as "deluding unwary and naïve patients."

Interpretation

The piece is a personal essay in the journal's Inklings section. The essay presents no new data. Rebar cites no study that measured the results of restorative care. His claims about how restorative clinicians work rest on his own view and career.

RRM Context

Restorative care evaluates both partners and seeks the causes of infertility. In a 2025 NaProTechnology study of 1,310 couples in Spain, urologists and andrologists examined the men. The men's work-up included semen analysis. The clinic found at least one cause of infertility in 98.1% of patients.

Abstract not indexed.

RRM Academy response · 13 October 2026

The essay cites no study of RRM and calls its patients unwary and naive

Robert Rebar's essay in Fertility and Sterility calls restorative reproductive medicine (RRM) a "nonmedical term" used "in a misleading manner" and says its proponents are "deluding unwary and naïve patients." The same essay declares "R.W.R. has nothing to disclose," while federal records list $13,650.63 in drug-maker consulting fees to him in the 36 months before it appeared online (Open Payments profile). It reports no data on RRM and cites no study of it.

  1. The essay cites no study of RRM care

    The essay reports no data of its own. Its five references are the author's own Merck Manual chapter, a 1999 paper on testicular sperm extraction, a 2021 ASRM Practice Committee opinion on evaluating infertile women, a 2020 ASRM guideline on unexplained infertility, and a WHO guideline paper listed as submitted. They concern infertility care in general and IVF. None studies what RRM clinicians do or how their patients fare.

    The essay's claims about RRM sit in its opening paragraph: that proponents focus "only or largely on the female," give undue emphasis to endometriosis, fertility awareness and lifestyle changes, ignore the full range of evidence-based interventions and may delay pregnancy. That paragraph cites nothing, and the essay doesn't mention the published RRM outcome studies.

  2. The essay calls patients unwary and naive

    The essay's last sentence reads: "These proponents are deluding unwary and naïve patients and couples." No study, case or survey stands behind it. It portrays the couples who chose restorative care as easily misled and says nothing of why they chose it or what happened to them.

    The published cohorts describe couples with long histories of infertility. In a 2008 cohort of 1,072 couples from an Irish general practice, couples had tried to conceive for a mean of 5.6 years, and 33% had already attempted assisted reproduction (ART, which includes IVF) (Stanford et al. 2008). In a 2025 cohort of 1,310 couples in Spain, prior ART attempts were recorded for 27.5% of couples (Sánchez-Méndez et al. 2025).

  3. RRM clinicians evaluate both partners

    The essay says RRM proponents "focus only or largely on the female." In the 2025 Spanish NaProTechnology cohort, a team of urologists and andrologists evaluated the men, with semen analysis and, when needed, sperm DNA fragmentation testing or testicular biopsy. Male factor was one of eight diagnostic categories (Sánchez-Méndez et al. 2025).

    In the 2008 Irish cohort, male factor was a diagnosis for 115 couples before NaProTechnology evaluation and for 146 after it (Stanford et al. 2008).

    The essay also says IVF doctors (reproductive endocrinologists) carefully consider all possible causes in both partners. A 2026 analysis of US commercial insurance claims followed patients whose care went on to IVF. Three months after a male infertility diagnosis, 6.0% of the men had completed the two semen analyses that AUA/ASRM guidance recommends, and IVF had already begun for 38.3% of that group (Parnell et al. 2026).

  4. Evaluation found a cause in nearly every couple

    In the 2008 Irish cohort, 506 couples arrived with a diagnosis of unexplained infertility. After NaProTechnology evaluation, 5 still carried it (Stanford et al. 2008).

    In the 2025 Spanish cohort, the clinic identified at least one cause of infertility in 98.1% of patients, with a mean of 2.5 diagnoses per couple. Hormonal disorders were the most common finding, in 85.6% (Sánchez-Méndez et al. 2025). The essay itself says many individuals with infertility have more than one cause. Restorative evaluation looks for each of them.

  5. Most successful pregnancies came in the first year

    In the 2025 Spanish cohort, the median time to conception was 7.1 months, and 72.4% of successful pregnancies occurred in the first year. The adjusted cumulative take-home baby rate was 62.1% (95% CI 58.8 to 65.4), and the crude rate was 35.3% (Sánchez-Méndez et al. 2025).

What the paper establishes

The essay establishes one physician's opinion, drawn from his own career. It gives readers nothing to weigh against RRM's published outcomes, and its description of patients as unwary and naive rests on no evidence.

Sources

  1. Open Payments profile openpaymentsdata.cms.gov
  2. Stanford et al. 2008 rrmacademy.org
  3. Sánchez-Méndez et al. 2025 rrmacademy.org
  4. Parnell et al. 2026 rrmacademy.org

By this author

Related research

Robert W Rebar
Bob Rebar, Rob Rebar, Bobby Rebar, R Rebar
PMID 41352767 41352767 DOI 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2025.09.015 10.1016/j.fertnstert.2025.09.015 Rebar et al. 2025, Rebar 2025