Lee, P., & Tham, J. (2021). Catholic Approaches to Procreation and Infertility. In Religion and Human Rights (pp. 19-28). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-86938-0_3
Lee P, Tham J. Catholic Approaches to Procreation and Infertility. In: Religion and Human Rights. 2021. p. 19-28. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-86938-0_3
Lee, Paul, and Joseph Tham. "Catholic Approaches to Procreation and Infertility." Religion and Human Rights, 2021, pp. 19-28.
Two authors argue Catholic ethics favors NaProTechnology over IVF
A 2021 book chapter by two Catholic authors argues that the Catholic Church favors NaProTechnology over IVF for couples with infertility. The authors compare the two approaches on results, side effects, and ethics.
Study at a glance, book chapter: Two authors argue Catholic ethics favors NaProTechnology over IVF. Source: Lee P et al., 2021, DOI 10.1007/978-3-030-86938-0_3.
Key Findings
The authors define Assisted Natural Procreative Processes as care that seeks the causes of infertility and corrects them by working with the woman's menstrual and fertility cycles.
The chapter traces the origin of NaProTechnology and the Creighton Model Fertility Care System to the Pope Paul VI Institute in the 1980s, with roots in the Billings Ovulation Method.
The chapter cites two retrospective NaProTechnology studies: a Canadian study reporting a success rate in 47% of couples and an Irish study reporting 52.8% in 1239 couples.
The chapter reports that over 41% of IVF pregnancies in the US in 2013 were multiple births and cites a higher incidence of prematurity and lower birth weight in IVF children.
Drawing on Dignitas Personae, the chapter identifies three goods that infertility care must respect: life, the unity of marriage, and the human values of sexuality.
Interpretation
The chapter is a two-author argument within a volume on religion and human rights. The authors reason from Church instructions and apply their three goods to IVF and to NaProTechnology in turn. They note that published effectiveness studies of NaProTechnology are few and call for further research and for teaching in medical education.
RRM Context
NaProTechnology, developed by Dr. Thomas W. Hilgers, treats infertility by finding its cause and working with the woman's cycle. IVF bypasses the reproductive system without resolving why conception fails. Restorative reproductive medicine evaluates both partners and uses cycle charting to time care.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract
Infertility is a worldwide problem today. The more conventional approach of medicine would be to diagnose the causes and correct them, so that the fertility potential of the couple would permit them to conceive naturally. However, since the advance of Assisted Reproductive Technologies, it has become a lucrative industry that seek to help anyone to procure a child. Lately, natural procreative processes such as NaProTechnology have arisen that can restore couples’ fertility potential through proper diagnosis and treatment. The Catholic Church prefers these latter approaches not only because they are truer to the nature of medical practice, but because they are more consistent with a healthy vision of human sexuality, procreation, and marriage.
The diagnostic and treatment philosophy behind RRM. How cause-based care differs from suppressive medicine, and what to expect from an RRM-trained clinician.
Ethics and Policy › Reproductive Ethics › Third Party Reproduction · Restorative Reproductive Medicine › Philosophy and Principles › Root Cause Approach
Paul Lee, Joseph Tham
P Lee, Joe Tham, Joey Tham, J Tham
DOI 10.1007/978-3-030-86938-0_3 10.1007/978-3-030-86938-0_3 Lee et al. 2021, Lee 2021