Restorative Reproductive Medicine NaProTechnology

Chapter 12: Decision Making in the CrMS

Hilgers TW

The Medical and Surgical Practice of NaProTECHNOLOGY, 215-219, 2004

RRM Academy Synopsis

Creighton Model charting helps couples decide each cycle on pregnancy

This textbook chapter presents the CREIGHTON MODEL System (CrMS) as a tool for couples to choose each cycle whether to try for pregnancy. Written from Catholic teaching, the chapter introduces mutually selective intercourse (MSI). The chapter also rejects providentialism, the practice of delaying any system until a grave and serious reason arises.

Key Findings

  • The chapter describes the CrMS as a system for a couple's entire reproductive life, used to seek or to postpone pregnancy. Seeking pregnancy refers to couples of completely normal fertility.
  • Providentialism, as the chapter defines it, means skipping charting and every system until a couple faces a grave and serious reason. The chapter suggests fertility nihilism may be a better name.
  • Citing Church teaching, the chapter states that spouses alone decide family size, and that physicians hold no right to dictate it.
  • The chapter introduces mutually selective intercourse (MSI) and puts one question first: whether the couple wishes to have another child.
  • The chapter holds that charting over time benefits the woman's health.

RRM Context

Creighton Model charting is one of the cycle-charting methods used in restorative reproductive medicine. Couples learn to read the woman's cycle. Teachers explain the information, and the couple decides how to use it. Restorative reproductive medicine treats the cycle as a source of health information, and charting gives both partners the same daily record to work from. That shared record supports decisions about seeking or postponing pregnancy, and it gives a clinician cycle data to work from when evaluating a problem.

Abstract

This chapter discusses decision making in the use of the CREIGHTON MODEL System (CrMS), which Hilgers presents as a system of “true” family planning that couples can use throughout their reproductive life both to achieve and to avoid pregnancy. Hilgers criticizes “providentialism,” in which couples do not chart or use any system until they have a grave and serious reason to avoid pregnancy, and calls the approach fertility nihilism. Drawing on Humanae Vitae and other Catholic Church teaching, the chapter states that the decision on how many children to have belongs to the spouses alone, and it introduces the term mutually selective intercourse (MSI) for the couple's choice in each cycle. The chapter also describes the conscious choice to achieve a pregnancy as co-creation with God and states that continued charting carries health benefits for the woman.

Read the guide

Topics

By this author

Related research

Restorative Reproductive Medicine › NaProTechnology › Protocols and Framework · Clinical Guidelines and Standards › Diagnostic Criteria and Classification › Diagnostic Criteria · Clinician Education and Training › Clinician Training › Professional Training
Thomas W Hilgers
Tom Hilgers, T Hilgers
Hilgers et al. 2004, Hilgers 2004