Chemical signals from eggs facilitate cryptic female choice in humans

Fitzpatrick JL, Willis C, Devigili A, Young A, Carroll M, Hunter HR, Brison DR

Published June 10, 2020 Proceedings. Biological sciences
DOI 10.1098/rspb.2020.0805 PMID 32517615 PMC PMC7341926

RRM Academy Synopsis

Follicular fluid around human eggs attracts sperm from specific men

Follicular fluid from different women attracted sperm from specific men in two laboratory experiments with samples from couples having IVF or ICSI. Follicular fluid surrounds a maturing egg. In both experiments, sperm gathered at similar levels in fluid from a partner and a non-partner.

Study at a glance, laboratory experiment of 16 couples: Follicular fluid drew sperm in a pairing-specific way
Study at a glance, laboratory experiment of 16 couples: Follicular fluid drew sperm in a pairing-specific way. Source: Fitzpatrick JL et al., 2020, PMID 32517615.

Key Findings

  • With fluid from two women offered at once (16 couples, eight blocks), sperm accumulation depended on the woman and man pairing (F8,32 = 19.38, p < 0.001).
  • With fluid from one woman set against a control medium (44 couples, 22 blocks), sperm responsiveness also depended on the pairing (F22,88 = 21.82, p < 0.001).
  • Follicular fluid drew almost 10 times more sperm (435.0 ± 39.0) than the control solution (45.1 ± 3.0).
  • In the simultaneous experiment, sperm gathered similarly in partner fluid (515.7 ± 79.9, mean ± s.e.) and non-partner fluid (441.9 ± 51.0), with p = 0.77.
  • Partner sperm preference did not predict clinical pregnancy (p = 0.40) or live birth (p = 0.27) after IVF. A fertilization-rate link (p = 0.02) came from two outlying points.

Interpretation

This laboratory experiment tracked sperm gathering in follicular fluid taken from women undergoing IVF or ICSI. The authors read the pairing effect as a sign that eggs may influence which sperm gather near them, a process they call cryptic female choice. The authors note that testing couples outside fertility treatment would be hard and ethically challenging. The findings support larger studies of this approach.

RRM Context

Chemical signals pass between the egg and sperm inside the body. The authors say IVF laboratory practice puts sperm close to eggs, which may reduce the role of these signals. They also cite 32% of UK couples in fertility treatment as having an unexplained cause. Restorative reproductive medicine evaluates both partners and treats unexplained infertility as undiagnosed.

Abstract

Mate choice can continue after mating via chemical communication between the female reproductive system and sperm. While there is a growing appreciation that females can bias sperm use and paternity by exerting cryptic female choice for preferred males, we know surprisingly little about the mechanisms underlying these post-mating choices. In particular, whether chemical signals released from eggs (chemoattractants) allow females to exert cryptic female choice to favour sperm from specific males remains an open question, particularly in species (including humans) where adults exercise pre-mating mate choice. Here, we adapt a classic dichotomous mate choice assay to the microscopic scale to assess gamete-mediated mate choice in humans. We examined how sperm respond to follicular fluid, a source of human sperm chemoattractants, from either their partner or a non-partner female when experiencing a simultaneous or non-simultaneous choice between follicular fluids. We report robust evidence under these two distinct experimental conditions that follicular fluid from different females consistently and differentially attracts sperm from specific males. This chemoattractant-moderated choice of sperm offers eggs an avenue to exercise independent mate preference. Indeed, gamete-mediated mate choice did not reinforce pre-mating human mate choice decisions. Our results demonstrate that chemoattractants facilitate gamete-mediated mate choice in humans, which offers females the opportunity to exert cryptic female choice for sperm from specific males.

By this author

Related research

John L Fitzpatrick, Charlotte Willis, Alessandro Devigili, Amy Young, Michael Carroll, Helen R Hunter, Daniel R Brison
Jack Fitzpatrick, J Fitzpatrick, C Willis, A Devigili, A Young, Mike Carroll, M Carroll, H Hunter, Dan Brison, Danny Brison, D Brison
PMID 32517615 32517615 DOI 10.1098/rspb.2020.0805 10.1098/rspb.2020.0805 Fitzpatrick et al. 2020, Fitzpatrick 2020