Ethics and Policy Reproductive Ethics

Conscientious Objection, Not Refusal: The Power of a Word

Jones-Nosacek C

Published August 2021 The Linacre Quarterly
DOI 10.1177/00243639211008271 PMID 34565898 PMC PMC8375369

RRM Academy Synopsis

An essay argues conscientious objection is the more accurate term

A 2021 essay by a retired family physician and bioethicist holds that conscientious objection describes physicians who decline an intervention better than conscientious refusal does. She says these physicians still treat the patient and act on reasoned principle. Of 30 papers using the refusal term over ten years, 18 appeared between 2017 and 2019.

Key Findings

  • Conscientious objection in medicine began in 1973, after Doe v. Bolton and Roe v. Wade. It later grew to cover sterilization, contraception, stem cell research, and care at the end of life.
  • A PubMed search on February 20, 2021 found that most published papers still use conscientious objection. Of 30 papers using conscientious refusal over ten years, 18 were published between 2017 and 2019.
  • Survey data the essay cites illustrate that question wording can shift responses: 71 percent approved a physician ending a patient's life by some painless means, and 51 percent approved assisting suicide.
  • The author reviews critics who argue that objecting physicians should choose another specialty or leave the profession. She holds that the word refusal implies a lack of access to care.
  • She concludes that conscientious objectors remain willing to treat the patient but decline to do so in a way that violates their conscience.

Interpretation

The article is a position essay by one author in The Linacre Quarterly, written from a Catholic healthcare view. The text combines history, dictionary definitions, a review of critics, and psychology research on framing. The word counts come from one PubMed search on a single date. They show how often each term appears in papers indexed in PubMed. The author states that patients generally have other options for care in the community.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine seeks the cause of a reproductive problem and treats it. Some clinicians in the field decline to prescribe suppressive medications such as hormonal contraception. Some also decline to perform sterilization. The essay lists both among the areas of conscientious objection. The choice of term shapes how guidance and policy describe these clinicians.

Abstract

Conscientious objection (CO) in medicine grew out of the need to protect healthcare providers who objected to performing abortions after the Roe v. Wade decision in the 1970s which has since over time expanded to include sterilization, contraception, in vitro fertilization, stem cell research, and end-of-life issues. Since 2006, there has been a growing amount of published literature arguing for the denial of CO. Over the last three years, there has also been an increase in calling this conscientious refusal. This article will argue that the term conscientious objection is more accurate than conscientious refusal because those who object are not refusing to provide care. CO also emphasizes that there are reasoned arguments behind one's decision not to perform certain actions because of one's own principles and values.

Summary

How something is presented matters. Objection emphasizes the thought behind the action while refusal gives the impression that medical care is not given.

Topics

Related research

Ethics and Policy › Reproductive Ethics › Conscience Protections
Cynthia Jones-Nosacek
C Jones-Nosacek
PMID 34565898 34565898 DOI 10.1177/00243639211008271 10.1177/00243639211008271 Jones-Nosacek et al. 2021, Jones-Nosacek 2021