Ethics and Policy Reproductive Ethics

Religion, conscience, and controversial clinical practices

Curlin FA, Lawrence RE, Chin MH, Lantos JD

Published February 8, 2007 The New England journal of medicine, 356(6), 593-600
DOI 10.1056/NEJMsa065316 PMID 17287479 PMC PMC2867473

RRM Academy Synopsis

Most US physicians say doctors who object must still disclose options

Most physicians say a doctor who objects morally must still present all options. A 2003 survey of US physicians in all specialties, on legal procedures patients request, estimated that nearly 9 out of 10 hold this view and about 7 out of 10 say the doctor must refer. Men and more religious physicians were less likely to report these obligations.

Key Findings

  • An estimated 63% of physicians say a doctor may ethically explain a moral objection, 86% say all options must be presented, and 71% say the doctor must refer the patient onward.
  • Fewer physicians with high intrinsic religiosity endorsed a duty to refer: 56%, against 82% with low (adjusted odds ratio, 0.3; 95% CI, 0.2 to 0.4).
  • Men were less likely than women to report a duty to disclose (odds ratio, 0.5; 95% CI, 0.3 to 0.9) or to refer (odds ratio, 0.5; 95% CI, 0.3 to 0.7).
  • Among respondents, 52% objected to abortion for failed contraception, 42% to birth control for adolescents without parental consent, and 17% to terminal sedation.
  • If opinions carry into practice, the authors estimate 14% of patients (more than 40 million Americans) have physicians who do not believe they must disclose, and 29% (nearly 100 million) for referral.

Interpretation

This cross-sectional survey drew a stratified random sample of 2000 US physicians aged 65 or younger, mailed in 2003. Of 1820 physicians reached, 1144 (63%) responded, and the results were weighted to represent US physicians overall. The findings describe what physicians say they owe patients when they object to a request. The authors note that stated duties may differ from actual practice. The findings support further study of how physicians' stated views carry into patient care.

RRM Context

The survey asks whether physicians must disclose all options. Restorative reproductive medicine looks for the cause of a problem and works with the ovulatory cycle, and patients can weigh that approach when clinicians describe it.

Abstract

Background

There is a heated debate about whether health professionals may refuse to provide treatments to which they object on moral grounds. It is important to understand how physicians think about their ethical rights and obligations when such conflicts emerge in clinical practice.

Methods

We conducted a cross-sectional survey of a stratified, random sample of 2000 practicing U.S. physicians from all specialties by mail. The primary criterion variables were physicians' judgments about their ethical rights and obligations when patients request a legal medical procedure to which the physician objects for religious or moral reasons. These procedures included administering terminal sedation in dying patients, providing abortion for failed contraception, and prescribing birth control to adolescents without parental approval.

Results

A total of 1144 of 1820 physicians (63%) responded to our survey. On the basis of our results, we estimate that most physicians believe that it is ethically permissible for doctors to explain their moral objections to patients (63%). Most also believe that physicians are obligated to present all options (86%) and to refer the patient to another clinician who does not object to the requested procedure (71%). Physicians who were male, those who were religious, and those who had personal objections to morally controversial clinical practices were less likely to report that doctors must disclose information about or refer patients for medical procedures to which the physician objected on moral grounds (multivariate odds ratios, 0.3 to 0.5).

Conclusions

Many physicians do not consider themselves obligated to disclose information about or refer patients for legal but morally controversial medical procedures. Patients who want information about and access to such procedures may need to inquire proactively to determine whether their physicians would accommodate such requests.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Ethics and Policy › Reproductive Ethics › Conscience Protections
Farr A Curlin, Ryan E Lawrence, Marshall H Chin, John D Lantos
F Curlin, R Lawrence, M Chin, Jack Lantos, J Lantos
PMID 17287479 17287479 DOI 10.1056/NEJMsa065316 10.1056/NEJMsa065316 Curlin et al. 2007, Curlin 2007