Genuis, S. J., & Lipp, C. (2013). Ethical diversity and the role of conscience in clinical medicine. International Journal of Family Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1155/2013/587541
Genuis SJ, Lipp C. Ethical diversity and the role of conscience in clinical medicine. International Journal of Family Medicine. 2013. doi:10.1155/2013/587541
Genuis, Stephen J., and Chris Lipp. "Ethical diversity and the role of conscience in clinical medicine." International Journal of Family Medicine, 2013.
For EndNote, Zotero or Mendeley:
Open access
No open license is recorded for this paper. Reuse terms are set by the publisher.
Open Access
Free full text on PubMed Central (PMC3876678)
RRM Academy Synopsis
Physician freedom of conscience should be protected, two authors argue
Two authors argue that physicians should keep freedom of conscience within accepted societal boundaries. The 2013 narrative review lays out the arguments on both sides. The review also presents a case study of one physician who stopped prescribing oral contraception.
Study at a glance, narrative review: Two authors argue physicians should keep freedom of conscience. Source: Genuis SJ et al., 2013, PMID 24455248.
Key Findings
The authors conclude that punishing health providers who act on deeply held conscience views about what is best for patients is intolerant, illegitimate and immoral.
The paper separates conscience issues into stress of conscience and freedom of conscience, and it focuses on freedom of conscience.
Opponents of conscience legislation say it erodes patient autonomy, while supporters say preserving conscience rights serves providers, patients and society.
In the case study, a physician decided to stop dispensing oral contraception after consulting on two young women with cerebrovascular events following the birth control pill. Colleagues generally responded unsympathetically.
The authors cite the Canadian Medical Association code, with 54 statements, and the World Medical Association code, with 22 duties, as guiding principles in conscience dilemmas.
Interpretation
The authors note that no quantitative research yet measures the impact of violating conscience on clinicians, and they call for that work. They state that physician accountability is required alongside conscience protections. Many supporters of conscience rights, they write, accept delineated boundaries on how those rights are exercised.
RRM Context
RRM works with the body's cycle and puts informed consent first. The case study centers on oral contraception, a suppressive medication. Colleagues were generally unaware of newer fertility monitors, and most lacked interest in them. Fertility awareness lets both partners plan or avoid a pregnancy without suppressing the cycle.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract
In a climate of plurality about the concept of what is "good," one of the most daunting challenges facing contemporary medicine is the provision of medical care within the mosaic of ethical diversity. Juxtaposed with escalating scientific knowledge and clinical prowess has been the concomitant erosion of unity of thought in medical ethics. With innumerable technologies now available in the armamentarium of healthcare, combined with escalating realities of financial constraints, cultural differences, moral divergence, and ideological divides among stakeholders, medical professionals and their patients are increasingly faced with ethical quandaries when making medical decisions. Amidst the plurality of values, ethical collision arises when the values of individual health professionals are dissonant with the expressed requests of patients, the common practice amongst colleagues, or the directives from regulatory and political authorities. In addition, concern is increasing among some medical practitioners due to mounting attempts by certain groups to curtail freedom of independent conscience-by preventing medical professionals from doing what to them is apparently good, or by compelling practitioners to do what they, in conscience, deem to be evil. This paper and the case study presented will explore issues related to freedom of conscience and consider practical approaches to ethical collision in clinical medicine.