Fitzgerald, J. E. (2016). Long-acting contraceptives for adolescents. The national Catholic bioethics quarterly, 16(1), 63-81. https://doi.org/10.5840/ncbq20161618
Fitzgerald, John E. "Long-acting contraceptives for adolescents." The national Catholic bioethics quarterly, vol. 16, no. 1, 2016, pp. 63-81.
For EndNote, Zotero or Mendeley:
License
Open-access status not yet checked.
RRM Academy Synopsis
Paper argues AAP's teen contraception policy opposes Catholic teaching
A 2016 Catholic bioethics position paper argues that the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) policy on teen contraception opposes Church teaching. The author, a retired law firm founder, says physicians in the United States who depart from the policy risk malpractice claims. He proposes a counseling program for Catholic schools, led by physicians.
Key Findings
The author reads the 2014 policy as recommending long-acting reversible contraception (LARC) first for adolescents, and argues that a physician who departs from that standard risks malpractice claims.
The 2014 statement encourages adolescents to delay sexual onset until they are ready. The author contrasts the 2007 statement, whose first recommendation was that pediatricians encourage sexual abstinence.
The author argues that hormonal implants and intrauterine devices can end a pregnancy, which he dates from fertilization, when ovulation occurs and fertilization follows.
He faults the policy for omitting risks he lists: sexually transmitted infections, certain cancers and future infertility.
The proposed model would have one or more lead physicians in each diocese, physician extenders, school visits from seventh and eighth grade, short video lessons and training in ovulation method charting.
Interpretation
This is a position paper. The author critiques the AAP's 2014 policy statement on legal and moral grounds. He founded the St. Augustine Foundation and is the retired founder of a medicolegal law firm. His legal argument addresses the standard of care in the United States, and his moral argument takes Catholic teaching on contraception as its premise.
RRM Context
The paper proposes teaching female students to chart their cycles. Restorative reproductive medicine shares that goal of body literacy and treats the ovulatory cycle as a vital sign. The paper's moral argument rests on Catholic teaching. Restorative reproductive medicine looks for the cause of cycle problems in how the body works.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract
In 2014, the American Academy of Pediatrics published its policy statement on contraception for adolescents, which provides, in effect, a mandate to temporarily sterilize all adolescents with long-acting reversible contraceptives for five to ten years. The author reviews the AAP guidelines and their effects on Catholic adolescents, their families, and adolescent health care providers. He then discusses medicolegal issues raised by the policy, outlines Catholic strategies for combating it, and proposes a diocese-based physician-led program for teaching and counseling elementary and high school students.