Current medical research: Summer/Fall 2016

Fehring RJ, Mu Q

Published February 2017 The Linacre quarterly, 84(1), 74-92
DOI 10.1080/00243639.2017.1278350 PMID 28392600 PMC PMC5375648

RRM Academy Synopsis

Most fertility apps in one review were not built to avoid pregnancy

Reviewers of 95 fertility apps found that most were not made to avoid pregnancy or built on an existing, evidence-based method. This 2016 digest also describes five education programs and a Danish study of pills and antidepressants.

Key Findings

  • Duane and colleagues found 95 apps. After exclusions, 40 remained, and only 6 of those scored perfectly when identifying the fertile days.
  • Moglia and colleagues judged only 20 of 108 free cycle apps accurate, defining accuracy as entering three full previous cycle lengths. In that review, 19% of the apps held incorrect medical information.
  • Dynamic Optimal Timing modeling put the cumulative unintended pregnancy rate at 4.4% across 13 cycles of correct use, for cycles of 20 to 40 days varying by 9 days or less.
  • All five fertility education programs, from five countries, raised knowledge significantly. In the Canadian study, scores fell back to their starting level by six months.
  • Among 1,061,997 Danish women, combined oral contraceptive users had a relative risk of 1.23 (95% CI; 1.22 to 1.25) for starting an antidepressant, compared with non-users.

Interpretation

The column summarizes published studies with commentary from its authors. The two app reviews used different scoring systems, and the column's author disputes one review's definition of accuracy. The Dynamic Optimal Timing estimate is theoretical, modeled from three earlier cycle datasets, and a large prospective study in the United States is testing how well the app helps women avoid pregnancy. The Danish study used national registers covering all Danish women aged 15 to 34.

RRM Context

Fertility awareness methods rely on observed signs such as cervical mucus, basal body temperature, and urinary luteinizing hormone. The column's author argues that app accuracy should be judged by those signs. The app reviewers call cycle tracking a way to follow the menstrual cycle as a vital sign. The Danish findings add to evidence on depression with suppressive hormonal contraception.

Abstract not indexed.

By this author

Related research

Richard J Fehring, Qiyan Mu
Rick Fehring, Dick Fehring, Rich Fehring, R Fehring, Q Mu
PMID 28392600 28392600 DOI 10.1080/00243639.2017.1278350 10.1080/00243639.2017.1278350 Fehring et al. 2017, Fehring 2017