Fehring, R. J. (2014). Current Medical ResearchWinter-Spring 2013. The Linacre quarterly, 81(1), 58-70. https://doi.org/10.1179/0024363913Z.00000000058
Fehring RJ. Current Medical ResearchWinter-Spring 2013. The Linacre quarterly. 2014;81(1):58-70. doi:10.1179/0024363913Z.00000000058
Fehring, Richard J. "Current Medical ResearchWinter-Spring 2013." The Linacre quarterly, vol. 81, no. 1, 2014, pp. 58-70.
Monitor users had fewer unintended pregnancies than mucus users
Couples using a fertility monitor had 7 unintended pregnancies per 100 women in a year, and couples tracking mucus had 18.5 per 100. The randomized trial of 667 couples appears in a 2014 Linacre Quarterly digest of natural family planning research. The digest also reviews postpartum charting and clinician training.
Key Findings
Couples were assigned at random to a ClearBlue Fertility Monitor with an algorithm or to mucus observation with an algorithm, then followed for 12 months.
Over the year, the monitor group had 7 unintended pregnancies per 100 women counting all causes, and the mucus group had 18.5 per 100 women.
When instructions were followed perfectly, the monitor group had 0 per 100 women and the mucus group had 2.7. The digest reports no significant difference between these two rates.
Couples still using their method fell from 82.2 percent at 3 months to 40.6 percent at 12 months with the monitor, and from 66.4 percent to 36.6 percent with mucus.
In a 198-woman postpartum cohort using a monitor protocol, 8 per 100 women had an unintended pregnancy by 12 months, and 2 per 100 did so with correct use.
Interpretation
The article is a digest of short reviews compiled by Richard J. Fehring for the Current Medical Research feature. Its main item summarizes a randomized trial, where a hazards regression model showed the monitor group's lower total rate to be significant. The reviewer notes that 19 percent of recruits provided no charts. The digest also reviews a postpartum cohort, a survey of OBGYN residents, a survey of 465 Title X clinic patients, an ovulation test trial, and a study of 107 regularly cycling women.
RRM Context
Fertility awareness with either mucus or urinary hormone readings gave low perfect-use rates in the trial. Such data help restorative clinicians pick methods for identifying the fertile window. The digest also reports a knowledge gap: 37 percent of 465 Title X clinic patients correctly named the fertile time of the cycle. Its author comments that varied LH surges should be expected even in regularly cycling women.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract not indexed.
By this author
Cycle Across the Lifespan · Cycle and General Health