Menstrual Cycle Cycle Biomarkers

Does scent attractiveness reveal women's ovulatory timing? Evidence from signal detection analyses and endocrine predictors of odour attractiveness

Mei M, Grillot RL, Abbey CK, Emery Thompson M, Roney JR

Published March 9, 2022 Proceedings. Biological sciences, 289(1970), 20220026
DOI 10.1098/rspb.2022.0026 PMID 35259990 PMC PMC8905178

RRM Academy Synopsis

Scent attractiveness poorly signals when a woman is ovulating

In a study of 46 undergraduate women who each gave six underarm scent samples, male raters discriminated fertile window timing from scent attractiveness very poorly. Samples near ovulation scored higher on average. Comparing samples within the same women, the mean discrimination score was 0.57, where 0.50 is chance.

Key Findings

  • Samples from two days before ovulation through the day of ovulation were rated more attractive than other days from the same women (γ = 0.27, p = 0.002, CI: [0.13, 0.37]).
  • Comparing samples within the same women, raters reached a mean AUC of 0.57, CI: [0.50, 0.64]. Across different women the mean AUC was 0.53, CI: [0.49, 0.57].
  • Within-women shifts in salivary estradiol and progesterone showed no significant link to shifts in odor attractiveness. The data were 10.73 times more likely without a progesterone effect than with one.
  • Women with higher mean estradiol had higher mean odor attractiveness (γ = 0.44, p = 0.04, CI: [0.30, 0.59]).

Interpretation

Forty-six women gave scent samples over about 30 days, and 61 men rated them. Urine tests gave ovulation timing for 32 of the women. Ratings rose on average near ovulation but overlapped so much with other days that the authors conclude ovulation timing is effectively concealed in scent attractiveness. The authors state that the findings apply only to ratings of scent attractiveness.

RRM Context

The researchers estimated ovulation with luteinizing hormone tests. Scent ratings gave raters little information about timing. Fertility awareness charting also ties the fertile window to signs measured in a woman's own cycle.

Abstract

Odour cues associated with shifts in ovarian hormones indicate ovulatory timing in females of many nonhuman species. Although prior evidence supports women's body odours smelling more attractive on days when conception is possible, that research has left ambiguous how diagnostic of ovulatory timing odour cues are, as well as whether shifts in odour attractiveness are correlated with shifts in ovarian hormones. Here, 46 women each provided six overnight scent and corresponding day saliva samples spaced five days apart, and completed luteinizing hormone tests to determine ovulatory timing. Scent samples collected near ovulation were rated more attractive, on average, relative to samples from the same women collected on other days. Importantly, however, signal detection analyses showed that rater discrimination of fertile window timing from odour attractiveness ratings was very poor. Within-women shifts in salivary oestradiol and progesterone were not significantly associated with within-women shifts in odour attractiveness. Between-women, mean oestradiol was positively associated with mean odour attractiveness. Our findings suggest that raters cannot reliably detect women's ovulatory timing from their scent attractiveness. The between-women effect of oestradiol raises the possibility that women's scents provide information about overall cycle fecundity, though further research is necessary to rigorously investigate this possibility.

Topics

Related research

Menstrual Cycle › Cycle Biomarkers › Hormonal Markers · Reproductive Endocrinology › Ovarian Hormones › Estrogen
Mei Mei, Rachel L Grillot, Craig K Abbey, Melissa Emery Thompson, James R Roney
M Mei, R Grillot, C Abbey, M Thompson, Jim Roney, Jimmy Roney, J Roney
PMID 35259990 35259990 DOI 10.1098/rspb.2022.0026 10.1098/rspb.2022.0026 Mei et al. 2022, Mei 2022