Efficacy of presacral neurectomy for the relief of midline pelvic pain

Metzger D, Montanino-Olivia M, Davis G, Redwine D

Published August 1994 The Journal of the American Association of Gynecologic Laparoscopists, 1(4), S22
DOI 10.1016/s1074-3804(05)80941-7

RRM Academy Synopsis

Presacral neurectomy added little pain relief to endometriosis surgery

In women having laparoscopic endometriosis surgery, a presacral neurectomy gave no substantial added relief of painful periods. This 1994 series compared 76 women who had it with 371 who did not.

Key Findings

  • The comparison group (CON) held 371 women, and 76 women formed the neurectomy group (PSN). All had laparoscopic ablation/excision of endometriosis.
  • Pain scores fell significantly from before surgery in both groups, for menstrual cramps and for other symptoms related to endometriosis.
  • After adjusting for each woman's starting pain level, the amount of relief was comparable in the two groups.
  • Stage I made up 25% (CON) and 38% (PSN) of each group. Stage IV made up 17% and 10%.

Interpretation

Patients rated their pain on a 0-5 scale before and after surgery. The ratings covered pain across the cycle, bowel and bladder symptoms, and daily function. The report is a 1994 AAGL meeting abstract. It compares records of women who had laparoscopic ablation/excision of endometriosis, some with a presacral neurectomy as well. The authors judge that cutting the presacral nerves adds little for painful periods once the endometriosis has been treated at surgery.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine looks for the cause of pelvic pain and treats it. In this series, menstrual pain improved after surgery aimed at the endometriosis, with or without cutting the pelvic nerves. Excision is the surgical standard for that goal.

Abstract

Presacral neurectomy has been advocated for severe dysmenorrhea when medical therapy fails to provide adequate relief. However, there are concerns regarding efficacy and the potential for postoperative complications. In order to address these concerns, questionnaires were used to assess the levels of pain (0-5 scale) before and after laparoscopic ablation/excision of endometriosis, which in some patients included a presacral neurectomy. Patients completed a preoperative and postoperative pain assessment to rate pain at different parts of the menstrual cycle, bowel symptoms, bladder symptoms, and general level of function. To date we have evaluated the records of 371 control patients (CON) and 76 patients who underwent a presacral neurectomy (PSN). Similar proportions of patients in each group were distributed among the different stages of endometriosis: Stage I, 25% (CON), 38% (PSN); Stage II, 28%/29%; Stage III, 31%/24%; Stage IV, 17%/10%. Significant improvement (by Wilcoxon signed rank test) over preoperative pain levels was found in both groups for menstrual cramps as well as other symptoms related to endometriosis. Even when controlled for preoperative pain level, comparable degrees of pain relief were observed in both groups. These results indicate that presacral neurectomy has no substantial benefit for the relief of dysmenorrhea over laparoscopic ablation/excision alone.

By this author

Related research

DOI 10.1016/s1074-3804(05)80941-7 10.1016/s1074-3804(05)80941-7 Metzger et al. 1994, Metzger 1994