Mental Health and Psychosocial Care Infertility Distress

Mood disorders, psychiatric symptoms, and distress in women presenting for infertility evaluation

Downey J, Yingling S, McKinney M, Husami N, Jewelewicz R, Maidman J

Published September 1989 Fertility and Sterility, 52(3), 425-432
DOI 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)60912-3 PMID 2776896

RRM Academy Synopsis

Infertility patients' depression did not differ from gynecology patients'

Women starting infertility evaluation did not differ significantly from routine gynecology patients on depression or symptoms in this 1989 study. It enrolled 59 infertility patients and 35 controls. About 75 out of 100 infertility patients said infertility had changed their mood. The authors suggest this distress may reflect mood problems that do not meet standard diagnoses.

Key Findings

  • The study enrolled 94 women: 59 infertility patients and 35 routine-care controls, from 740 women screened at three private gynecology offices.
  • Major depression at some point in life affected 32.2% of infertility patients and 48.6% of controls (P = 0.174). A current episode affected 8.5% and 2.9% (P = 0.522).
  • Infertility patients and controls did not differ on any of the 12 Brief Symptom Inventory scales, on partner relationship satisfaction (P = 0.194), or on self-esteem (P = 0.930).
  • Among infertility patients, 74.6% reported that infertility had affected their mood, 49.2% a change in sexual functioning, and 44.1% a change in self-esteem.
  • Infertility patients also noticed changes in their partners: 33.9% a change in mood and 32.2% a change in sexual functioning.

Interpretation

The baseline comparison came from a prospective, longitudinal study of women at the first stage of evaluation in the New York City area. Both groups scored above published norms for women who were not patients on 7 of 9 symptom scales. The authors note that the comparison group does not constitute a normal control group.

RRM Context

Women reported distress, mood change and strain in sexual functioning in the early stages of evaluation. Restorative reproductive medicine considers the whole person and the couple. It considers the emotional state of both partners alongside the search for the cause.

Abstract

Women who undergo treatment for infertility frequently report depression, but it is crucial to distinguish between subjective distress, symptoms, and clinical depressive disorders. In the initial assessment of a prospective, longitudinal study, 59 women presenting for infertility treatment were compared with 35 women presenting for routine gynecological care. Infertility patients and controls were not significantly different on self-report measures of partner satisfaction, sexual functioning, or self-esteem. There was also no difference in psychiatric symptomatology, or in the percentage of subjects who were currently experiencing or had ever experienced a major depressive episode. However, the infertility patients perceived themselves to have been already quite affected by their inability to conceive. For instance, 49.2% reported changes in their sexual functioning and 74.6% reported changes in their mood.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Mental Health and Psychosocial Care › Infertility Distress › Anxiety and Depression in Infertility
Jennifer Downey, Sandra Yingling, Mary McKinney, Nabil Husami, Raphael Jewelewicz, Jack Maidman
Jen Downey, Jenny Downey, J Downey, S Yingling, M McKinney, N Husami, R Jewelewicz, John Maidman, J Maidman
PMID 2776896 2776896 DOI 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)60912-3 10.1016/s0015-0282(16)60912-3 Downey et al. 1989, Downey 1989