Planned hospital birth versus planned home birth

Olsen O, Clausen JA

Published September 12, 2012 The Cochrane database of systematic reviews
DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD000352.pub2 PMID 22972043 PMC PMC4238062

RRM Academy Synopsis

No strong trial evidence for home or hospital birth in low-risk women

Randomized trials give no strong evidence favoring planned home or hospital birth, a 2012 Cochrane review of low-risk women concludes. Two trials qualified. Only one, with 11 women, supplied outcome data, which the authors judged too small for conclusions.

Key Findings

  • Of two eligible randomized trials, only one supplied outcome data, and it enrolled 11 women.
  • In the United Kingdom trial, 11 of 71 invited women (15%) agreed to be randomized to home or hospital birth.
  • Most mothers randomized to hospital reported disappointment with the allocation, and none randomized to home did (Peto odds ratio 12.18, 95% confidence interval 1.05 to 141.17; Fisher's exact test P = 0.07).
  • The Dutch trial, awaiting classification, was set where 30% of all births are home births. The authors say well-informed women there seem unwilling to be randomized.

Interpretation

The authors limited the review to randomized trials and rated the one usable trial as moderate quality, since its confidence intervals were wide. The trial enrolled multiparous women in the United Kingdom, recruited in one area where few women otherwise chose planned home birth. Findings apply to selected low-risk women. The authors suggest trials may be worthwhile where home birth is available but little known. They add that a regularly updated review including observational studies might matter equally.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine extends cause-based care into pregnancy and birth. The review describes a midwifery model of care built on protecting normal labor. Observational studies it cites report lower intervention rates with planned home birth. One study of 13,000 births reported cesarean section in 5.2% versus 8.1% (RR 0.64, 95% CI 0.56 to 0.73), lower in the planned home group.

Abstract

Background

Observational studies of increasingly better quality and in different settings suggest that planned home birth in many places can be as safe as planned hospital birth and with less intervention and fewer complications. This is an update of a Cochrane review first published in 1998.

Objectives

To assess the effects of planned hospital birth compared with planned home birth in selected low-risk women, assisted by an experienced midwife with collaborative medical back up in case transfer should be necessary.

Search Methods

We searched the Cochrane Pregnancy and Childbirth Group's Trials Register (30 March 2012) and contacted editors and authors involved with possible trials.

Selection Criteria

Randomised controlled trials comparing planned hospital birth with planned home birth in low-risk women as described in the objectives.

Data Collection and Analysis

The two review authors as independently as possible assessed trial quality and extracted data. We contacted study authors for additional information.

Main Results

Two trials met the inclusion criteria but only one trial involving 11 women provided some outcome data and was included. The evidence from this trial was of moderate quality and too small to allow conclusions to be drawn.

Authors' Conclusions

There is no strong evidence from randomised trials to favour either planned hospital birth or planned home birth for low-risk pregnant women. However, the trials show that women living in areas where they are not well informed about home birth may welcome ethically well-designed trials that would ensure an informed choice. As the quality of evidence in favour of home birth from observational studies seems to be steadily increasing, it might be as important to prepare a regularly updated systematic review including observational studies as described in the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions as to attempt to set up new randomised controlled trials.

Related research

Ole Olsen, Jette A Clausen
O Olsen, J Clausen
PMID 22972043 22972043 DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD000352.pub2 10.1002/14651858.CD000352.pub2 Olsen O; Clausen et al. 2012, Olsen O; Clausen 2012