Williams, D. H. (2010). Sperm banking and the cancer patient. Therapeutic advances in urology. https://doi.org/10.1177/1756287210368279
Williams DH. Sperm banking and the cancer patient. Therapeutic advances in urology. 2010. doi:10.1177/1756287210368279
Williams, Daniel H. "Sperm banking and the cancer patient." Therapeutic advances in urology, 2010.
For EndNote, Zotero or Mendeley:
Open access
Free to read
No reuse license
Open Access
Free full text on PubMed Central (PMC3126065)
RRM Academy Synopsis
Sperm banking before cancer care gives men the best chance to father
A 2010 narrative review concludes that sperm freezing before treatment gives men the best chance of becoming biological fathers. The review describes how cancer drugs, radiation, surgery and the cancer itself affect fertility. Fewer than a quarter of cancer patients bank sperm, most often because they lack information.
Key Findings
Fewer than a quarter of cancer patients bank sperm. Lack of information is the most common reason given.
Over 90% of responding oncologists felt every man with cancer should be offered banking before treatment, yet almost half did not offer it.
Among 1388 testicular cancer survivors, 422 had cryopreserved semen after orchiectomy. Only 29 men (7%) used their banked semen for assisted reproduction (ART).
At one institution, 11.6% of men who wished to freeze sperm were azoospermic (no sperm in the ejaculate), from 3.9% with non-Hodgkin's lymphoma to 15.3% with testicular tumors.
In one cited study, 27% of men had abnormal semen parameters before treatment. After treatment, 23% of men developed azoospermia.
Interpretation
This narrative review pulls together published studies and survey data on male fertility and cancer treatment. The author concludes that banking sperm before treatment gives men their best chance of becoming biological fathers. Many men miss this chance because patients and oncologists lack clear information about banking. The author notes that outcomes of assisted reproduction using banked sperm have mostly been reported in case reports and small studies. The findings support wider patient education and further study of how banked sperm is used after cancer treatment.
RRM Context
Cancer treatment, and in some studies the cancer itself, can lower semen quality. Male fertility belongs in every couple's evaluation. In men left azoospermic by treatment, sperm production often returns, after months to years. Among 218 cancer survivors who had banked sperm and returned for semen analysis after treatment, 20 reported a spontaneous pregnancy. Restorative reproductive medicine seeks the cause of reduced fertility in both partners. Assisted reproduction goes around that cause and leaves it in place.
Our editorial summary of this paper, not the article's abstract.
Abstract
The current concepts, recommendations, and principles of sperm banking as it pertains to the comprehensive care of young men of reproductive age with cancer are reviewed. Obstacles to sperm banking are addressed as well as future directions for fertility-preserving technologies. All cancer therapies-chemotherapy, radiation, and surgery-are potential threats to a man's reproductive potential. In addition, cancer itself can impair spermatogenesis. Thus, sperm cryopreservation prior to initiating life-saving cancer treatment offers men and their families the best chance to father biologically related children and should be offered to all men with cancer before treatment. Better patient and provider education, as well as deliberate, coordinated strategies at comprehensive cancer care centers are necessary to make fertility preservation for male cancer patients a priority during pretreatment planning.