Male Fertility Male Factor Treatment

The effects of tomato juice on male infertility

Yamamoto Y, Aizawa K, Mieno M, Karamatsu M, Hirano Y, Furui K, Miyashita T, Yamazaki K, Inakuma T, Sato I, Suganuma H, Iwamoto T

Published January 5, 2017 Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 26(1), 65-71
DOI 10.6133/apjcn.102015.17 PMID 28049263

RRM Academy Synopsis

Sperm motility rose more with tomato juice at 6 weeks in infertile men

Daily tomato juice seemed to improve sperm motility at 6 weeks in infertile men, a randomized trial of 44 men in three groups found. The motility increase was not seen at 12 weeks. The antioxidant capsule group had no significant improvement in semen measures.

Study at a glance, randomized trial of 44 men: Tomato juice raised sperm motility at 6 weeks, not at 12
Study at a glance, randomized trial of 44 men: Tomato juice raised sperm motility at 6 weeks, not at 12. Source: Yamamoto Y et al., 2017, PMID 28049263.

Key Findings

  • Of 54 men recruited, 44 completed the study: 17 in the tomato juice group, 15 in the antioxidant group and 12 in the control group.
  • After 12 weeks of tomato juice, plasma lycopene increased significantly (p=0.017) and seminal plasma lycopene increased as well (p=0.023); the two levels correlated (r=0.36, p=0.024).
  • In the tomato juice group, sperm motility rose more from baseline than in controls at 6 weeks (p=0.019), and seminal white blood cells fell more at 12 weeks (p=0.039).
  • Compared directly with the control group, semen parameters in the tomato juice group and the antioxidant group showed no statistically significant difference.
  • Semen volume decreased at 12 weeks compared with the control group in both the tomato juice group (p=0.037) and the antioxidant group (p=0.035).

Interpretation

Men with poor sperm concentration or motility were randomly assigned to tomato juice, an antioxidant capsule, or no supplement for 12 weeks. Of the 54 men recruited, 44 completed the study. The motility gain showed up in change-from-baseline comparisons at 6 weeks and was not seen at 12 weeks. The authors note that normal week-to-week variation in one man's motility may account for that difference. Direct comparisons between the tomato juice group and the control group found no statistically significant difference in semen measures. The authors point to lycopene as the likely active ingredient and call for a larger study of tomato juice in men with low sperm motility.

RRM Context

Restorative reproductive medicine evaluates both partners. The paper's introduction puts male factors at 25-50% of infertility causes and cites a report naming oxidative stress as a likely cause of male infertility. The authors test a lycopene-rich food that may protect sperm. They cite an earlier lycopene study in men with no known cause for low sperm counts, which reported improvement in many semen measures.

Abstract

Background and Objectives

This study aimed to investigate the effects of tomato juice consumption on seminal plasma lycopene levels and sperm parameters in infertile men.

Methods and Study Design

Subjects were male infertility patients with poor sperm concentration (<20×10 6/mL) and/or motility (<50%). Following a fourweek observation period, subjects were randomly assigned among three groups: a tomato juice group, an antioxidant group, and a control group. The subjects in the tomato juice group and the antioxidant group daily consumed one can of tomato juice (containing 30 mg of lycopene) or one antioxidant capsule (containing vitamin C 600 mg, vitamin E 200 mg, and glutathione 300 mg), respectively, for 12 weeks (feeding period). Seminal plasma lycopene levels and sperm parameters were measured every 6 weeks during the feeding period.

Results

Forty-four patients completed the study (control group: 12, antioxidant group: 15, tomato juice group: 17). In the tomato juice group, plasma lycopene level was significantly increased at the 12th week of the feeding period. Moreover, a decrease in seminal plasma white blood cells and an increase in sperm motility in the tomato juice group were statistically significant at the 12th and 6th weeks, respectively, compared to the control group. In the antioxidant capsule group, no significant improvement was observed in semen parameters.

Conclusions

In conclusion, regular consumption of tomato juice seems to improve sperm motility in infertile patients. This is the first report to show that commercially available food, such as tomato juice, might be beneficial for male infertility.

Topics

By this author

Related research

Male Fertility › Male Factor Treatment › Medical Management
Yu Yamamoto, Koichi Aizawa, Makiko Mieno, Mika Karamatsu, Yasuko Hirano, Kuniko Furui, Tatsuya Miyashita, Kazumitsu Yamazaki, Takahiro Inakuma, Ikuo Sato, Hiroyuki Suganuma, Teruaki Iwamoto
Y Yamamoto, K Aizawa, M Mieno, M Karamatsu, Y Hirano, K Furui, T Miyashita, K Yamazaki, T Inakuma, I Sato, H Suganuma, T Iwamoto
PMID 28049263 28049263 DOI 10.6133/apjcn.102015.17 10.6133/apjcn.102015.17 Yamamoto et al. 2017, Yamamoto 2017