Trends in perinatal health after assisted reproduction: a Nordic study from the CoNARTaS group

Henningsen A, Gissler M, Skjaerven R, Bergh C, Tiitinen A, Romundstad L, Wennerholm U, Lidegaard O, Nyboe Andersen A, Forman J, Pinborg A

Published March 2015 Human Reproduction, 30(3), 710-716
DOI 10.1093/humrep/deu345

RRM Academy Synopsis

Birth outcomes after ART improved over two decades as twin births fell

A Nordic registry cohort found that birth outcomes among children conceived with ART improved over two decades as twin births became less common. Researchers followed 62 379 singletons and 29 758 twins in Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden, born 1988 to 2007, and matched them with spontaneously conceived children.

Key Findings

  • Researchers compared 62 379 ART singletons and 29 758 ART twins with 362 215 spontaneously conceived singletons and 122 763 spontaneously conceived twins.
  • Twin deliveries after ART held at 23% until 2002, then dropped to 11.6% in 2007. That year Denmark had 18.6% and Sweden 5.6%.
  • Preterm birth among ART singletons fell across the period, most steeply early on. Preterm birth among ART twins stayed unchanged.
  • From 1990 onward, singleton stillbirth from 28 weeks showed no significant gap between ART and spontaneous conception. Among singletons, a gap in infant death persisted in the late period.
  • Using a statistical estimate, the authors put monozygotic twins at 3.5% of ART twins and 32% of the spontaneous twin controls.

Interpretation

The design is a registry-based matched cohort, so the findings are associations between calendar period and outcomes. The authors could not adjust for BMI, smoking, duration of infertility or cause of infertility, and the treated population shifted over time, which may have shaped the trends. The main trend analyses combined IVF, ICSI and frozen embryo transfer, with separate comparisons by method. The study did not test why outcomes improved.

RRM Context

The authors credit fewer multiple births as the main driver. ART bypasses the reproductive system without resolving why conception fails, so the cause of infertility remains a separate question from the health of the child. Restorative reproductive medicine starts by diagnosing and treating that cause in both partners. Infant death among ART singletons stayed above the spontaneous rate in the late period.

Abstract

STUDY QUESTIONS: Has the perinatal outcome of children conceived after assisted reproductive technology (ART) improved over time?

Summary Answer

The perinatal outcomes in children born after ART have improved over the last 20 years, mainly due to the reduction of multiple births.

WHAT IS KNOWN AND WHAT THIS PAPER ADDS: A Swedish study has shown a reduction in unwanted outcomes over time in children conceived after ART. Our analyses based on data from more than 92 000 ART children born in four Nordic countries confirm these findings.

Study Design

Nordic population-based matched cohort study with ART outcome and health data from Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden.

PARTICIPANTS, SETTING AND

Methods

We analysed the perinatal outcome of 62 379 ART singletons and 29 758 ART twins, born from 1988 to 2007 in four Nordic countries. The ART singletons were compared with a control group of 362 215 spontaneously conceived singletons. Twins conceived after ART were compared with all spontaneously conceived twins (n = 122 763) born in the Nordic countries during the study period. The rates of several adverse perinatal outcomes were stratified into the time periods: 1988-1992; 1993-1997; 1998-2002 and 2003-2007 and presented according to multiplicity.

Main Results and the Role of Chance

For singletons conceived after ART, a remarkable decline in the risk of being born preterm and very preterm was observed. The proportion of ART singletons born with a low and very low birthweight also decreased. Finally, the stillbirth and infant death rates have declined among both ART singletons and twins. Throughout the 20 year period, fewer ART twins were stillborn or died during the first year of life compared with spontaneously conceived twins, presumably due to the lower proportion of monozygotic twins among the ART twins.

Limitations, Reasons for Caution

We were not able to adjust for some potential confounders such as BMI, smoking, length or cause of infertility. The Nordic ART populations have changed over time, and in recent years, both less as well as severely reproductive ill couples are being treated. This may have affected the observed trends.

Wider Implications of the Findings

It is assuring that data from four countries confirm an overall improvement over time in the perinatal outcomes of children conceived after ART. Furthermore, data show the beneficial effect of single embryo transfer, not only in regard to lowering the rate of multiples but also concerning the health of singletons.

Study Funding/Competing Interests

The European Society for Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE), the University of Copenhagen and the Danish Agency for Science, Technology and Innovation has supported the project. The CoNARTaS group has received travel and meeting funding from the Nordic Federation of Obstetrics and Gynecology (NFOG). None of the authors has any competing interests to declare.

By this author

Related research

Rolv Skjaerven, Julie Lyng Forman, Anja Pinborg
R Skjaerven, J Forman, A Pinborg
DOI 10.1093/humrep/deu345 10.1093/humrep/deu345 Henningsen et al. 2015, Henningsen 2015